Updated 12:58 pm.EST, Sat November 21, 2009

Society|Wed, Sep. 05 2007 11:17 AM EDT

Latino Evangelicals May Ditch GOP Over Immigration Reform

By Michelle Vu|Christian Post Reporter

WASHINGTON – Prominent Latino evangelical leaders expressed their disappointment at Republican lawmakers’ lack of support for the recent immigration reform bill, leading an expert to predict that the GOP presidential hopefuls may have lost their Latino evangelical voters base.

  • illegal immigrants
    (Photo: AP Images / Jacquelyn Martin)
    Fernando Guillen, of Woodbridge, Va., center, who is originally from El Salvador, marches in protest down Prince William Parkway in Woodbridge, Va. on Sunday Sept. 2, 2007. Over 4,000 people attended the march and rally, held in protest of measures passed this July by Prince William county to deny a potentially wide range of public services to illegal immigrants. Marchers were also concerned that the measures will lead to racial profiling of Latino immigrants.

Republican senators were held responsible for derailing this summer’s comprehensive bipartisan immigration reform bill. Three-quarters of the Senate’s Republicans voted to kill the bill, which fell 14 votes short of the 60 needed to limit debate and move toward final passage of the legislation. Republican opponents denounced the bill as amnesty for providing a plan which allowed the country’s 12 million illegal immigrants to become U.S. citizens.

“They completely abandoned us,” said the Rev. Samuel Rodriguez, president of the National Hispanic Leadership Conference, according to The Dallas Morning

Rodriguez, a Republican proponent, tried to rally support among Republican senators for a bill which he considers a moral and biblical response to the immigration crisis.

“We were divided on global warming, but not on immigration,” commented Rodriguez, noting Hispanic leaders in all 50 state chapters of the NHLC believe Latino evangelicals will now not show up at the polls for Republicans.

The NHCLC is the largest Hispanic Evangelical organization in the United States, representing some 15 million evangelical members. The NHCLC is the sister organization of the National Association of Evangelicals.

Rodriguez’s prediction should strike Republican White House hopefuls as a serious problem given statistics on Latino Protestant voting trend.

In 2004, President George W. Bush received 68 percent of the voting population who identified themselves as Latino Protestant who attended church weekly. Although the group was not a dominant voting base for Bush, swing groups such as Latino evangelicals can play a significant role in close elections, pollster John Green of the Pew Forum on Religion & Public Life said to the Dallas Morning News.

Rodriguez, and others like him, are now questioning whether they can label the GOP party as the “party of Jeff Sessions, Tom Tancredo and James Sensenbrenner” who were strong opponents of the immigration bill, or the party of George W. Bush and John McCain who are both strongly in favor of the bill.

White House negotiators along with the group of bipartisan senators helped draw up the immigration bill which has been President Bush’s top domestic priority in his second term. Bush had even made a rare personal appearance on Capitol Hill to plead with Republican senators to support the bill.

Another Latino evangelical leader who agreed that the immigration issue could really hurt Republican candidates is the Rev. Lynn Godsey, who works with Latino Protestants in North Texas. Godsey said the only Republican presidential candidate in good standing with Latino evangelicals is Sen. John McCain of Arizona.

The Rev. Mark Gonzalez of Dallas said some Latino evangelicals will continue to vote Republican, but others will switch to Democrats or stay home.

“I usually like to suggest how candidates or officials can head off a coming disaster,” wrote William McKenzie, editorial columnist of the Dallas Morning News. “This one’s hard because most of the GOP presidential contenders are running away from the Bush-McCain line on immigration. That means they are only digging a deeper grave with a natural Republican constituency.”

McKenzie advised Republican lawmakers and presidential hopefuls to make more efforts to speak to Latino evangelical leaders. He noted that President Bush has met twice this year already with Latino evangelical pastors.

“But Republicans are moving into the post-Bush era,” commented McKenzie. “As they do, Latino evangelicals may not go with them.”

Sort by: Newest | Oldest | Agree | Disagree
All comments on this page are subject to our Terms of Use and do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post or its staff.
  • Thu Sep 20, 2007 8:16 am Agree: 1   Disagree: 2

    Dave: "Deported back to heaven"? Sheeze. Do the math sir. Much more has been taken from our society than is given by illegals. Any small, in comparison, amount they pay in taxes is paltry to what they are stealing from our country. Your analysis of the situation, and comparisons to the Bible, are simplistic at best. Yours is more, like most folks, based on emotion; other than the facts. Respectfully yours.....

  • Dave »
    Fri Sep 14, 2007 12:37 pm Agree: 1   Disagree: 1

    Dhster,This can also be made that majority of illegal aliens are paying taxes, From the earliest years of the CLINTON ADMIN. millions of illegal aliens were given FED.ID'S numbers for the exact purpose of paying taxes, and millions more until this very day.The case can also be made that millions of Americans are defrauding the Goverment in billions of dollars in SS,Medicare,Medicaid,Check Fraud,Credit Card Fraud,InsuranceFraud,Food Stamp Fraud, Katrina Hustler Fraud and the list goes on..And also Millions of Canadians arein the country illegally and they are not deported..And reg GOD and Laws my premise is not false because Pilate the Roman Governor cooperated with the Jewish Priest thus making them CIVIL AUTHORITIES to crucify JESUS and deporting HIM back to HEAVEN...

  • Thu Sep 13, 2007 6:18 pm Agree: 0   Disagree: 2

    Dave: The case can be made that illegal immigrants are committing thefts of jobs, educational, and medical services. The aiding/abetting of such are felonies by federal law. If someone broke into your house/property, and refused to leave, would that not be against the Bible's command to obey the civil authorities? It also says that God instituted the civil authorities, and that they do not carry the sword in vain. What Christ was speaking about was the so-called religious laws of the Jewish priests, not those of the civil authorities. So I believe that your premise is false.

  • Dave »
    Tue Sep 11, 2007 10:38 am Agree: 2   Disagree: 0

    DEUTERONOMY 24 V14, "YOU SHALL NOT OPPRESS A HIRED SERVANT WHO IS POOR AND NEEDY, WHETHER ONE OF YOUR BRETHERN OR ONE OF THE ALIENS WHO IS IN YOUR LAND WITHIN YOUR GATES".

  • Dave »
    Mon Sep 10, 2007 9:41 pm Agree: 2   Disagree: 0

    Let's remember people MOSES and JOSHUA were iILLEGAL ALIENS too when they migrated from EGYPT to ISRAEL... ALso in MATT 25 V43 JESUS said "I WAS AN ALIEN AND YOU DID NOT TAKE ME IN".....

  • Dave »
    Mon Sep 10, 2007 9:33 pm Agree: 2   Disagree: 0

    To Art, A person robbing a bank is a FELON , this act falls under the 8th COMMANDMENT tTHOU SHALL NOT STEAL. Unlawful entrance and presence in this country is only a misdemeanor equivelant to speeding.And there is no COMMANDMENT that saids THOU SHALL NOT CROSS THE BORDER...And Regarding you asking how does GOD feel about people ignoring MAN-MADE LAWS.. I tell yoiu look at MARK 3V4 JESUS asked the PHARISEES " IS IT LAWFUL TO HEAL ON THE SABBATH". AT this point JESUS knew HE was breaking their MAN-MADE LAWS(Border is a man-made law) JESUS then healed the man,He then looked at them with anger because they put their MAN-MADE LAWS over HUMAN SUFFERING..

  • Sat Sep 08, 2007 11:00 am Agree: 3   Disagree: 4

    The "Hispanic Evangelicals" are what I consider a racist group. Where is Christ in this? They are divisive and power hungry in my point of view. Are we going to be divided by race in heaven?

  • Sat Sep 08, 2007 9:32 am Agree: 0   Disagree: 1

    If our Latino brothers and sisters in Jesus put an issue, such as immagration, or drug legalization, we can hope that the love of Christ will be preserved.
    I think Congress is to blame for most our problems not God, so when one breaks the law, any law one should ask is it an addiction, is it sinful, is there any break in fellowship with the Lord.
    People are tained with causes, and ignorance, but one will reap what one sows.

  • Fri Sep 07, 2007 4:40 pm Agree: 4   Disagree: 3

    Hi Art, I only quoted one Matthew verse, which is a tenet of the Christian faith. In contrast, the verse you quoted about “rendering unto Caesar...” is a favorite of those who use it to demonize unauthorized migrants. I always have to explain that verse: Jesus was answering a trick question posed by the Pharisees about paying taxes to Caesar. In no way was He commanding us to blindly submit to unjust laws. He did however, repeatedly command us to help the less fortunate. (You conveniently left out “and to God the things that are God’s”.)

    As such, I plan to go to Arizona next summer to work with some church groups that provide humanitarian aid to migrants crossing the desert. About as many have died over the past several years as did on 9/11, and about 500 will die in the most horrible way this year. I will do this because there’s no fine-print in Matthew that says that our “brothers” have to be documented Christians before we can feed or clothe them. That notion would be entirely inconsistent with the Gospel message and would exclude about 70% of the world! Even it were the correct interpretation, more Hispanic immigrants are Christian (94%), than are native-born white U.S. citizens (82%).

    You seem intelligent so I’m sure you know that your analogy between bank robbery and unauthorized immigration is kind of absurd, right? Currently, sneaking into the U.S. is a minor civil offense that hasn’t even been criminalized as a misdemeanor. What punishment fits the minor offense of sneaking in to work for food? Is deportation a just punishment? After they’ve paid their dues, even bank robbers get paroled and get to “go forth and sin no more”.

    When I wrote, tongue in cheek, that “Jesus was the ultimate illegal,” I meant that in effect, He was also an unauthorized migrant worker who was later persecuted. He moved about freely and entered unauthorized areas to do His work helping sinners. His words were indeed subversive and “illegal” according to Jewish and Roman laws. He was seen as a threat to security, arrested, tried, convicted and thusly crucified with other convicted criminals by His side.

    You’re right about no other countries having open borders, but just like us, the wealthy nations have serious illegal immigration problems too. Europe is currently dealing with a wave of African and Muslim immigrants. Recently, many have provided amnesty like we did in 1986. I believe that in the end, the most moral nations will be the ones that deal with these “least of our brothers” in the most humane and just manner.

    The U.S. is by far the wealthiest nation. We take in much more than our fair share of the world’s wealth and resources, and our population density is relatively low. I think much is expected of the luckiest 4.6% of the world’s people, most of us who, by no effort of our own, happened to pop out of our mama’s womb on the right side of the border.

  • artm »
    Fri Sep 07, 2007 1:27 pm Agree: 3   Disagree: 4

    Hi don quixote, You have quoted some great passages of Scripture there, The only thing wrong is that you take them completly out of contex.

    I f I went by your logic, A bank robber could come to you and you would give them refuge, and hide them from the police, you would would bring them food every day and keep them from answering for their crime.
    And you said that Jesus was an Illegal in His day, How does what Jesus do comparable to Illegal Immigration ?

    God never told Christians to help people break the law, You are wrong.

    You refer to the Immigration laws of the United States Immoral, What country in the world do you know of that allows people to cross its boarders anytime they please without going through the lagal process.?

    Also the only way a person can be the brother or sister of a Christian is for them to be born again, do you beleive that all 12 million people are saved.?

    No sir, You are wrong in the way you intrept the Word of God here.

    I am not against any people, Yet I do beleive we are to obey the law of the land where it does not oppose the Law of God.

    Jesus said, " Render to Ceasor the things that are Cearsors"

    Oh yea, Thats even with all those pesky forgive and love one another verses.

    Art.

  • Thu Sep 06, 2007 1:08 pm Agree: 2   Disagree: 5

    If Jesus' words are truly to be our guide in the illegal immigration debate, the most pertinent verses are in Matthew:

    "I was a stranger, and you invited Me in… you gave Me something to eat… to the extent that you did it to … even the least of my brothers, you did it to Me.”

    This message is at the heart of the Christian doctrine, and is what drives churches to defy the system and support helpless unauthorized migrants. Moral law always takes precedence, since even our own "Nation of Laws" can get it wrong.

    It should be crystal clear that the “least of [our] brothers” today are the 12 million unauthorized migrants who have escaped a desperate situation simply to do our hardest jobs for food. Yes, they committed a minor offense per our dysfunctional and obsolete immigration laws, but who wouldn’t do the same in their shoes? In Matthew, Jesus says that these lowly souls living in the shadows of our society are in essence Him.

    We forget that Jesus frequently entered unauthorized areas to help an assortment of "illegals" and other undesirables. Due to His “crimes,” He was deported (straight back to Heaven!) by the legal authorities of the day. The Roman Empire was also a “Nation of Laws.” And illegal is illegal, right? Jesus was the ultimate illegal.

    There are also numerous examples of our national heroes defiantly breaking immoral and unjust laws. Our national founders were revolutionaries and were in effect, the first “illegals” on U.S. soil. The first Civil Rights activists broke several laws (Rosa Parks, MLK, Cesar Chavez, etc.)

    Our national (and Christian) identity is largely built on the spirit of open defiance of hypocritical and unjust systems of authority.

    Oh yeah, and then there are those pesky forgive and love one another verses…

  • Thu Sep 06, 2007 8:21 am Agree: 1   Disagree: 0

    artm,

    :^)

  • artm »
    Thu Sep 06, 2007 4:30 am Agree: 7   Disagree: 5

    I can show you something sadder than that. People who claim to know God, And yet will tell people to continue to break the law which God tells us not to do.

    Makes you wonder what kind of life they must live.

    Show me Scripture where it tells us that what is being done is alright. Show me in the Bible where being " Illigal " is Gods will and choice.. You cant, so you want people to just role with the world and call it Christian to do so. no one has answered my questions concerning the Word of God, Just more talk, Not about says about the subject.

    It's sad when people are willing to throw the Word of God out the window when it comes to their own benefit. and their own agenda. Art.

  • Wed Sep 05, 2007 11:02 pm Agree: 4   Disagree: 4

    I agree with you Daviel. It is sad to see the arrogance, self-righteousness, and general lack of understanding that many evangelicals have towards immigrants. The folks who will demand that a violation of the law be seen as a sin when it comes to immigration are the same folks who have no problem encouraging others to break the law when it comes to school prayer, abortion, displays of the ten-commandments in public places. They say God’s higher law overrides the secular laws of the land, but somehow that isn’t the case for immigration, which is one area where secular law mysteriously overrides God’s law.

    But the saddest thing is you can’t show them anything to convince them otherwise. They’ve got their propaganda, they’ve got their proof-texts, and they’ve got their politics, it’s biblical hermeneutics done by a nationalist political ideology.

    Thomas Rasmussen
    http://didymuspov.blogspot.com/

  • artm »
    Wed Sep 05, 2007 8:27 pm Agree: 6   Disagree: 5

    How many of those Illigal Immigrants are born again ? Because only then would they be brothers and sisters. God does not ask Christians to break the law, that would be sin.

    all may come to america, only let them come legally. And I would like to see some pressure put on the mexican government to care for its people, I really wonder why that is not done.

    calling someone a racist because they don't agree with Illegal activity is actually judging wrongly.

    I am not against any people coming to america, But I do beleive that the Word of God tells them to do it legally. we should base our beleifs on the Word of God,Not nationality.

    I wonder how the mexican government reacts to anyone found in their country Illigally.

    Art.

  • Wed Sep 05, 2007 7:14 pm Agree: 4   Disagree: 7

    THE REPUBLICANS AN THE LATINO COMMUNITY

    I am really dissapointed on how the U.S. Goverment is treating the Latino community. To those who complain against the so called "illigal immigration" I would like to ask them, Did the first pilgrims who came to America came "legally"? And if yes, How that happen? It is sad how some people conveniently forget history. But this only reflects how evangelical Christians are FAR AWAY from biblical principles of helping those in need.

    I think we really need a SECOND REFORMATION here and now in order to return to the Bible because America today is nurturing herself not from the Bible, but from a man made christianity. It is a shame to see how well intentined Christians are promoting racism and prejudice against brothers and sisters in Christ for the only reason of being from diferent nationality, or what it is worse accusing them of terrorists.

    But I think this procedure is caused and fomented because of the bias in the media. Sadly, many christians only show their ignorance and bigotry instead of the christian love that our Lord commanded us to have all who really know Him and obey Him.

    Daviel

  • artm »
    Wed Sep 05, 2007 3:19 pm Agree: 3   Disagree: 4

    I hope my Latino brothers and Sisters in Christ understand that God tells us to obey the law of the land unless that law is against His Word.

    The Bible also tells us not be be partakers of other mens sin. to sneak across the border Illeagally is against the law of the United States of America. Therefore,it is sin to do so.

    It is sin unless you can find in the Word of God where it says it is not, Or where it says it is the will of God for this to be.

    The Mexican Goverment is failing its people, It is a corrupt Goverment that is stealing from the people.

    I love the Mexican People, My daughter is married to a mexican, And I have 5 beautiful grand children from this marriage.

    But the law is the law,unless you can show where it is against Gods law.

    Art.

    t

Please help us to monitor our message boards by flagging comments that are unlawful, harmful, threatening, abusive, harassing, defamatory, vulgar, obscene, libelous, hateful, or racially, ethnically or otherwise objectionable.
Contact Us if you have any questions, comments, or concerns.
Comment on this story
ID Password

Don't have a Christian Post ID? Signing up is easy. Click Here

  • icon1
  • icon2
  • icon3
  • icon4
  • icon5
The Christian Post reserves the right to terminate the account of any User who violates our Terms of Use.
Advertisement
Advertisement
CP Shopping
  • Jewelry
  • Health
  • Gifts
  • Music
  • Coins

Bracelets | Chains | Crosses | Earrings | Gemstone |

Featured contents & Giveaways
Joolwe :
Cross-pendant necklace
Zondervan

Struggling to succeed in the Nashville music scene, talented singer/songwriter Parker James finds the competition fierce even deadly. A young woman's murder, industry corruption, a

Featured Advertiser Links