Advanced Search

Dutch Lawmaker Releases Anti-Quran Film

By
Toby Sterling
Associated Press Writer
Fri, Mar. 28 2008 06:15 PM ET
[-]Text[+]
E-mail Print RSS More on Topic AddThis Button

AMSTERDAM, Netherlands (AP) - A Dutch lawmaker released a film highly critical of Islam on Thursday, setting verses of the Muslim holy book against a background of violent images from terrorist attacks.

Geert Wilders posted his 15-minute film on a Web site. Shortly afterward, Dutch television channels showed segments of the film and broadcast discussions by analysts on the possible impact of its release..

The Dutch government had warned Wilders that a film offensive to Muslims could spark violent protests in Islamic countries, like those two years ago after European newspapers published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad.

"The film equates Islam with violence. We reject this," Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende said in a televised reaction. "We ... regret that Mr. Wilders has released this film. We believe it serves no other purpose than to cause offense."

Dutch television refused to broadcast the film, and Wilders had difficulty finding an Internet platform willing to host it.

The film shows statements from radical clerics and cited verses from the Quran interspersed with images of the Sept. 11 attack on the United States, the 2004 commuter train bombings in Spain and the murder later that year of Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh on an Amsterdam street.

His movie begins and ends with one of the caricatures of Muhammad, accompanied by the sound of a page being torn from a book.

Subtitles assure viewers that the page was not torn from a Quran, but from a telephone book. "It's not up to me, but the Muslims to tear the hate-sowing pages out of the Quran," the subtitles add.

After the release, Wilders told reporters that he made the film because "Islam and the Quran are dangers to the preservation of freedom in the Netherlands in the long term, and I have to warn people of that."

The film is called "Fitna," an Arabic word that can be translated as "ordeal." Wilders suggested European culture is under threat due to immigration by Muslims.

"It's five minutes before midnight and this is the last warning as far as I'm concerned," he said.

Early reaction was muted.

Yusuf Altuntas, of the Contact Group Muslims and Government, said Wilders "is seeking the limits, but not crossing the line. For Mr. Wilders, this is quite subtle."

The film was not as jarring as anticipated, said Maurits Berger, professor of Islam in the West at Leiden University.

"It's a series of images and photos, headlines from recent years which we already know," he said.

The film tells more about Wilders than the Quran, Berger said. "It represents his fear of Islam."

The lawmaker put out his film on the evening before a Dutch judge was due to hear a petition bu a Muslim group seeking an independent review of the film to see whether it violates hate speech laws. The Dutch Islamic Federation asked the court to impose a fine of $79,000 for every day the film is available to the public.

Mohamed Rabbae, chairman of the moderate National Moroccan Council, which appealed for calm in January ahead of the film's release, said he had heard about "Fitna" but not yet seen it.

Wilders "collected some bloody pictures and related them to some verses in the Quran," Rabbae told The Associated Press. "On the one hand, this is less bad than we thought he was going to do. But he also gives the impression the Quran justifies violence, and that is really wrong."

Associated Press writer Mike Corder in The Hague contributed to this reporter.

Copyright 2008 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

BACK TO TOP Print E-mail More on Topic AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Comments

Most recent comments
da6383ma
  • Mon Mar 31, 2008 6:12 pm
  • : 1
  • : 0
  • Flag
To ProfessorX: Thanks for the thanks,....But I also personally believe that the Lucifer,...who is an "outcast cherub"from the Kingdom of G--d,....is smart enough to "hybid" into another definition thanks to "Islamiphobia",..
and produce a package that "almost everyone is happy with" to which he will be on top of anyhow,..By G--d`s Scripture there are absolute steps that HAVE TO take place before the second coming of the C---t,...this is all the Will of G--d,....according to the last pages of the Main Book,...So,...just like Hitler started campaining to the "Worker Party"and then became the "National Workers Party compliments of Hitler and people thought he was such a great ortator,...and snowballing thereafter,....This seems like the same thing,...just on a WAY larger scale,...can one say Socialism and Totalarism straight across the board???
ProfessorX
  • Mon Mar 31, 2008 5:22 am
  • : 2
  • : 0
  • Flag
Thank you for that link. I will post it around the world. Islam shall be no more forever. Muhammad was, is, and forever will be a False Prophet!!! Muhammad had a demon. That's why he encouraged his followers to serve the moon god idol who demanded the killing others as they kill themselves, also pillage and destroy their neighbors. Muhammad’s miracles were false as well as his words. Only Satan (thief) came to kill steal and destroy but Jesus came to give abundant life and peace with God. John10:10

Muslims, now acknowledging the violent and barbaric inception and the devilish beliefs of their religion, are now in a race to redefine what they stand for today. As a result, they are now forced to disregard the teachings of Muhammad (founder of Islam).

When Muhammad had his “so-called” revelations he fell to the ground groveled in the dirt and foamed at the mouth in a DEMONIC fit just as Joseph Smith did, founder of Mormonism.

The mission and vision of Arab Television is to perpetuate misinformation in order to create pandemic Arab hysteria that will send more of them to lives of self-destruction, futility, and to reproduce this dysfunction to the next generation.

http://evolutionfacts.blogspot.com
da6383ma
  • Sat Mar 29, 2008 10:08 pm
  • : 2
  • : 0
  • Flag
I believe G. Wilders "Fitna" may or may not have been a little rich for some peoples blood,..with the "Sensationalism" but if one can sit through 1hr and 38 minutes of this "What the West must know"......very educational,..what the likes of Robert Spencer and Walib Shoebat have to say on the subject are pretty sobering by any standards, I believe,...very sobering.......http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-871902797772997781&q=what+the+west+needs+to+know&total=1736&start=0&num=100&so=0&type=search&plindex=0
tamna
  • Sat Mar 29, 2008 8:57 pm
  • : 2
  • : 0
  • Flag
First, I read this:

"The Dutch government had warned Wilders that a film offensive to Muslims could spark violent protests in Islamic countries, like those two years ago after European newspapers published cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad."

And then the very next papargraph I read this:

"The film equates Islam with violence. We reject this," Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende said in a televised reaction.

Uhhh, am I the only one who sees the obvious contradiction in these two statements. First, there is a fear of VIOLENT protests. Then the politician says that Islam does not equate with violence.

My question is this, if there is nothing to fear about islam, why do you fear the almost routine violence from those who follow this 7th century science fiction book?

It seems to me this is nothing more than another version of "Islam is a religion of peace. And we'll kill anyone who doesn't agree."

I have another question. Where was all the concern from muslims for religious respect when Christianity of Judaism is insulted by muslims? Hypocrites.
wrhalver
  • Sat Mar 29, 2008 6:34 pm
  • : 0
  • : 1
  • Flag
Freedom of speech carries great responsibility. Our forefathers fought for the opportunity to demonstrate that America would get it right.

As Christians, we should be concentrating more on the hate that exists between our splintered denominations, and less on other faiths that may not agree with our GodHead.
Gratus
  • Sat Mar 29, 2008 1:37 am
  • : 3
  • : 0
  • Flag
Wilders, John14-6 and Gig are right, I am afraid. Islam is indeed a hateful, inherently violent and wicked religion. I cry for millions of ignorant, peace loving people held captive in its sway. I pray for them. Let us show the love of Jesus to one another and to these poor people! When we speak the truth, let us speak the truth in love, not compromising the truth, but also not elevating ourselves on pedestals of judgmentalism (cf Mat 7:1f).
gig
  • Fri Mar 28, 2008 11:45 pm
  • : 3
  • : 0
  • Flag
i watched Fitna last night and it was scarey, horrifying, sad and made me furious. There is a deep set anger primarily against the Jews that has been placed in these people since day 1 thousands of years ago. It is irrational, insane, hateful, arrogant and downright CRAZY. They are very threatening, and use fear of certain death against anyone that comes against them. They are similar to the Nazis, and in fact had ties during WWII with them.
I can't say enough about how they torment their women and screw up their own flesh and blood, not hesitating in the least to kill a family member. What a miserable life they lead. What a horror-laden existence to be a Muslim, anywhere.
john14-6
  • Fri Mar 28, 2008 5:55 pm
  • : 5
  • : 0
  • Flag
Wonderful! Mr. Wilders is to be commended. He is making and releasing the film to prove a point, and he has made that point before it was even released. I have seen the film and it is a devastating and powerful condemnation of the hateful, inherently violent and wicked religion of Islam. It goes a long way to show that Islam is a creation of the devil himself. I highly recommend everyone here view the film, however if you don't have a strong stomach you might want to be careful - he includes many images that are graphic and disturbing but still, these are images that people in the West *need* to see.
Please help us to monitor our message boards by flagging Abusive, Spam, Offensive, Illegal, Racist or Libellous Posts.

Comment on this story

ID Password
Submit Don't have a Christian Post ID?Signing up is easy. Click Here