St. Mary’s Catholic Church in downtown Greenville, South Carolina may not have the largest congregation but this week Father Jay Scott Newman’s post-election comments loomed large on the national scene. Father Neman is one of four priests who minister to the Upstate parish. In a letter posted on the church website Father Newman wrote “voting for a pro-abortion politician when a plausible pro-life alternative exists constitutes material cooperation with intrinsic evil.” He went on to call abortion the “chief battleground” in the culture war because “abortion is usually murder in secret and it lays the axe to the human life at the root.”
But, as strong as they were, it wasn’t these statements that caused Father Newman’s comments to be picked up by the national media. It was his belief that parishioners who voted for Obama should not receive Holy Communion until they repent. Father Newman hastened to say that church teaching doesn’t allow him to refuse people Holy Communion based on their vote but most news media outlets chose to ignore that statement, running headlines that suggested he would deny the sacrament to Obama voters. Those in the media who thought Father Newman’s position represented a new approach to church polity must have slept through the 2004 election when Missouri Catholic Bishop Raymond Burke declared that he would offer a blessing but not full Communion to then Democrat presidential candidate John Kerry, who is both Catholic and pro-abortion.
After Father Newman’s letter was posted, about fifty people showed up outside St. Mary’s to rally in support of his position. When Father Newman rose to speak at the Saturday afternoon Mass, he was greeted by an extended and emotional standing ovation from the more than 200 parishioners who were present. E-mails sent to Father Newman were running nine to one in favor of his letter.
Why was there such an outcry both for and against Father Newman’s position? The positions taken by those who support and those who condemn Father Newman’s strong stand against abortion represent a deep rift among Catholics who attend Mass regularly and those who are Catholic in name only. A recent survey conducted by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life revealed that only 25 percent of the 65 million self-proclaimed Catholics in America attend Mass each Sunday. And although Election Day exit polls show that 54 percent of self-identified Catholics voted for Barack Obama, when you break the numbers down by regular attendance for Mass, McCain wins 55 percent to Obama’s 43 percent. Devout, practicing Catholics who know what their church teaches on the moral issues of the day are still solidly behind the Republican Party. The same is true of Protestants who faithfully attend church at least once a week and who consciously put into practice the teaching of their faith.
People responded to Father Newman’s stand because they are hungry for spiritual leaders who stand up, speak up, and then back up what they say with action. In his first letter to the church at Corinth, Paul asked, “If the trumpet makes an unclear sound, who will prepare for battle?” Ezekiel reminded the watchmen of Israel “If anyone hears the sound of the trumpet but ignores the warning, and the sword comes and takes him away, his blood will be on his own head. However, if the watchman sees the sword coming and does not blow the trumpet, so that the people aren’t warned, and the sword comes and takes way their lives, then they have been taken away because of their iniquity, but I will hold the watchman accountable for their blood.” (Ezekiel 33:4,6). Continue >>
RSS
“Voting for a pro-abortion politician when a plausible pro-life alternative
exists constitutes material cooperation with intrinsic evil.â€Â
-- Father Jay Scott Newman
Guys like this are just begging to have their rears kicked, but when you try,
they say, "You would hit a man wearing a dress?"
I'm getting tired of these blinded leaders who confuse their politics with "God's orders."
Besides, the "plausible pro-life alternative" was a war-mongering old man.
Does God not care about Muslim children having their arms & legs blown off?
“Voting for a pro-abortion politician when a plausible pro-life alternative
exists constitutes material cooperation with intrinsic evil.â€Â
-- Father Jay Scott Newman,
Guys like this are just begging to have their rear kicked, but when you try,
they say, "You would hit a man wearing a dress?"
I'm getting tired of these "religious" leaders who confuse their politics with "God's orders."
Besides, the "plausible pro-life alternative" was a war-mongering old man.
Does God not care about Muslim children having their arms & legs blown off?
Wow, blue, you're right! I might as well just give up my moral standings, since no man is perfect. Thanks for pointing that out.
"Hath God REALLY said thou shalt not eat of any tree in the garden?"
Oh, blue, you know we look for more than abortion that they do not support.
So let's vote for a warlord, a racist, a pedophile, a pro-war, pro-gun, a gay, a sexist, or heck! even a - shock, muslim! As long as they don't support abortion... please. Prolife + prowar = the 'right' choice? Hypocrisy!!!
believer,
Nicely helped.
forgiven, if I might help, Christians who are truly committed to the cause of Christ and His clear teachings found in the Word of God are more likely to vote for a Pro-Life candidate and Christians who are not truly committed to the cause of Christ and disregard the clear teachings in God's Word are more likely to vote for a Pro-Abortion candidate.
For more on father Newman and what he said, see http://www.lifenews.com/state3639.html
It's not working.
Let's try this way.
This is exactly the issue facing the Catholic church. For way to many years, as I see it, people have claimed to be Catholic similar to a nationality, but never actually practicing and/or participating in the religion. I see, though, because of this election the increased effort to correct this by Catholic leaders. Good for them.
This does not exclude any other denominations or non-denominations from this similar issue ~ non-attendance, which leads to non-growth in the knowledge of Him.
Opps ~ take two
Dr. Beam writes: "A recent survey conducted by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life revealed that only 25 percent of the 65 million self-proclaimed Catholics in America attend Mass each Sunday. And although Election Day exit polls show that 54 percent of self-identified Catholics voted for Barack Obama, when you break the numbers down by regular attendance for Mass, McCain wins 55 percent to Obama’s 43 percent."
This is exactly the issue facing the Catholic church. For way to many years, as I see it, people have claimed to be Catholic similar to a nationality, but never actually practicing and/or participating in the religion. I see, though, because of this election the increased effort to correct this by Catholic leaders. Good for them.
This is an important lesson for all denominations or non-denominations to take from this issue ~ non-attendance, which leads to non-growth in the knowledge of Him.
Dr. Beam writes: "A recent survey conducted by the Pew Forum on Religion and Public Life revealed that only 25 percent of the 65 million self-proclaimed Catholics in America attend Mass each Sunday. And although Election Day exit polls show that 54 percent of self-identified Catholics voted for Barack Obama, when you break the numbers down by regular attendance for Mass, McCain wins 55 percent to Obama’s 43 percent."
This is exactly the issue facing the Catholic church. For way to many years, as I see it, people have claimed to be Catholic similar to a nationality, but never actually practicing and/or participating in the religion. I see, though, because of this election the increased effort to correct this by Catholic leaders. Good for them.
This is an important lesson for all other denominations or non-denominations regarding this issue ~ non-attendance, which leads to non-growth in the knowledge of Him.