NEW ORLEANS – Police on Tuesday cleared out two New Orleans Catholic churches occupied by former parishioners opposed to the archdiocese's decision to close them, breaking down a door at one.
Two protesters were arrested and at least two more were issued citations, police said.
"It's our property. It's our church. It belongs to the Archdiocese of New Orleans," said The Very Rev. Michael Jacques, a member of the archdiocese's Council of Deans.
Officers forced open the door at Our Lady of Good Counsel in the city's Uptown neighborhood, arresting two people occupying the building, and issued one of the summons to a protester occupying St. Henry's, also in Uptown.
Parishioners calling themselves the Friends of Our Lady of Good Counsel had occupied their church since October, when the archdiocese closed it and several others in an economic move to consolidate parishes following Hurricane Katrina and shifting populations of Catholics in the area.
St. Henry's parishioner Cynthia Robidoux, 46, said she received a summons to appear in municipal court after brokering a deal with police to allow others keeping vigil to leave.
"It's unbelievable. They stole my church," Robidoux said of the archdiocese.
The church viewed the parishioners as trespassers and called police after the protesters repeatedly refused to leave. They said a routine inspection of church property on Monday found that the doors at Our Lady of Good Counsel were locked and barricaded.
Archdiocese spokeswoman Sarah Comiskey said parishioners were removed to protect the safety and security of the buildings and the people occupying them, which included children and the elderly.
"The archdiocese all along had hopes for a peaceful resolution to the occupations, but recent events made it necessary for us to go forward," Comiskey said.
Cheron Brylski, a parishioner who was outside Our Lady of Good Counsel, said the group had been trying to mediate the dispute with the archdiocese. "Instead, they are using force," she said.
Police used a battering ram to break down the church's back door, said Poppy Z. Brite, one of the two people arrested at Good Counsel.
Brite, a local author of eight novels, said she and another protester were booked and charged with criminal trespass and resisting arrest and were released without bond to appear Wednesday in Municipal Court.
A third person taken from the church in handcuffs was Harold Baquet, 50, a photographer for Loyola University of New Orleans. Brylski, Baquet's wife, said police put him in a patrol car and took him home.
One of the protesters who was not arrested, Dorothy Payton, 72, said Tuesday was the first day she had participated in the vigil. She said police told the group inside the church that they would be arrested. "They started praying the Rosary. That's when they handcuffed them and walked them out," she said.
In November, a state court judge dismissed a lawsuit by the parishioners seeking to keep Our Lady of Good Counsel open, saying the group did not have standing to sue. Brylski said they were appealing that ruling.
The closing was part of a reorganization begun early in 2008 to reduce the number of parishes. In all, 36 have been closed.
Archbishop Alfred Hughes has said the archdiocese must downsize to survive population changes and structural damage caused by Katrina and a shortage of priests.
New Orleans' Catholic population has been shifting for decades as descendants of Irish, Italian, French and German immigrants moved from the city's older areas and into the suburbs, where new church parishes have grown.
About one-third of New Orleans' pre-storm population of 455,000 has not returned, though it was not clear how many were Catholics.
Associated Press Writer Janet McConnaughey contributed to this story.
RSS
This was more of a personal territorial issue for the church members, this church must of had a historical significance for their community. It is unfortunate, but their efforts should be geared towards the Lord ,because he is forever and a building is only temporal.
"Now, there's the love of the Catholic church at work...."
And there's the love of a Christian in action. Or not.
Doctrinal truth without compassion sounds harsh and judgmental.
nolalady, thank you for giving some backstory without being judgmental; your post should lead to greater understanding. It is indeed a sad situation in a city struggling to recover. We should remember that many parishioners lost most everything in hurricane Katrina; they are simply trying to hang on to or regain some sense of normalcy.
1Co 3:16 Do you not know that you are a temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwells in you?
Perhaps more energy should be spent being witnesses for God than witnesses for a Temple.
Not to add any point of view but just to give points of clarification.
-- certain churches were closed, others were combined. the people have nearby churches to worship at, they are opposed to their particular church closing.
-- Archbiship Hughes is not very well liked by catholic lay people and priests in New Orleans. He was involved in shifting priests around known to abuse children. So, people are apalled that child molesting priests were not arrested but these people were.
IHS,
Amen.
Now, there's the love of the Catholic church at work....
"It's our property. It's our church. It belongs to the Archdiocese of New Orleans," said The Very Rev. Michael Jacques, a member of the archdiocese's Council of Deans.
If you want to get right down to the nitty gritty, it's God's Church and He's just letting the Diocese make use of it.
This is sad. Hopefully soon, they will build newer and safer holy buildings of God for these people to worship.
If anyone is this bothered by a physical building, they have a twisted understanding of what church is (an assembly of believers).
After the flood, there would be no master key at the Archdioce level. They could have a key made easilly, but the doors were blocked and baricaded so people would not go in for fear they would be hurt by the building which was in bad shape.
Much like a construction site that is not ready for people, these buildings and churches suffered massive structural problems with the amount of water that came through.
Let us pray for these people to find a solution, so they may worship the Lord as they have done in the past.
Despite our theological differences . . . my heart goes out to these people. They should consider meeting in someones home and begin a new.
Hello Daniel Paul:
According to the article, the doors were locked AND barricaded. A key doesn't help much with a barricade.
PAX
I'm confused. Why didn't one of the leaders of the Catholic church show up with a key to let the police in? Surely they had a key.