Town Divided Over Dismissal of Ohio School Teacher

Evolved1 »

Wed Jul 09, 2008 1:51 pm Agree: 4   Disagree: 1

CGN,

Respectfully, I think you need to look more closely at the facts of the story. Mr. Freshwater was not barred from being identified as a Christian, nor denied his rights to believe as he chooses. He was under contract with the school district to adhere to the approved curriculum, which he did not do. He taught creationism as an alternative to evolution, which is not approved curriculum.

Whether he agreed with the material or not, it was his job first and foremost to follow the rules. His actions are known as insubordination. What kind of example does it set for the kids when they see a teacher disobey the rules?

The children "taught" by Mr. Freshwater had to be re-taught basic science principles by the next teacher to have them. Creationism has a place, it is called church. Science class is not the appropriate place for it. I haven't seen calls for evolution to be taught at church, so why should creationism get preferential treatment? They each have a time and place, and that's where they're supposed to stay.

Mr. Freshwater should become a full-time youth pastor. It seems to be his calling. If he still insists on being a teacher, then the school district must insist that he follow the rules. Insubordination alone is grounds for suspension or termination.

Then there is the "cross burned on the arms" issue. He misused a piece of the school's equipment by marking a cross on students' arms. Knowingly using a device improperly could also lead to suspension or termination.

Obviously when all is combined, it is clear that action had to be taken. To not take action would show support for insubordination and incompetence. That would be a dangerous precedent to set, and had to be avoided.

Mr. Freshwater should do the right thing and drop any appeals he might be making. It will only further divide the people and make waves where there needn't be any. If he truly had the children's best interest in mind, this is the course he would take.

Let's hope that happens.

Evolved1

Town Divided Over Dismissal of Ohio School Teacher

Evolved1 »

Tue Jul 08, 2008 8:26 pm Agree: 0   Disagree: 0

Oh yeah, and one that won't burn the children either... That's important.

Town Divided Over Dismissal of Ohio School Teacher

Evolved1 »

Tue Jul 08, 2008 8:24 pm Agree: 0   Disagree: 0

Hopefully now they will hire someone that actually teaches the children science, and not hire another youth pastor for the position...