UMC high court says conference can close Hispanic church in California

Quick Summary

  • The UMC Judicial Council ruled Monday that the California-Pacific Conference followed the Book of Discipline in its closing of La Trinidad UMC in Los Angeles.
  • The conference cited concerns over church funds and attendance, which fell to 10 people.
  • A new ministry, Nueva Esperanza, now carries on United Methodist work in East Los Angeles.

An artificial intelligence-powered tool created this summary based on the source article. The summary has undergone review and verification by an editor.

Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank preaches a sermon at Community United Methodist Church of Coeur d’Alene in July 2026.
Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank preaches a sermon at Community United Methodist Church of Coeur d’Alene in July 2026. | YouTube/Community United Methodist Church of Coeur d'Alene

The highest court of the United Methodist Church (UMC) has upheld a regional body’s decision to close a predominantly Hispanic congregation in California.

The United Methodist Judicial Council issued Decision Number 1526 on Monday, centering on whether the UMC California-Pacific Conference could close La Trinidad United Methodist Church in Los Angeles “under exigent circumstances.”

The court ruled that the conference had properly followed the process for closing La Trinidad UMC, upholding an earlier decision from California-Pacific Bishop Dottie Escobedo-Frank.

Specifically, the Judicial Council concluded that the conference followed ¶ 2549.4(b) of the UMC Book of Discipline, which details the policy on developing a plan to transfer membership of a church.

This process allows a conference to “declare a local church closed” through “a recommendation by the district superintendent, and with the consent of the presiding bishop,” followed by approval from “a majority of the district superintendents, and the appropriate district board of church location and building.”

“In the alternative, the annual conference may declare a local church closed in response to a petition submitted jointly by the local church’s church council, appointed or assigned pastor in charge, and at least one of its lay members of the annual conference,” the section continues.

“If the annual conference closes a local church, title to all the real and personal, tangible and intangible property of the local church shall immediately vest in the annual conference board of trustees, who shall hold said property in trust for the benefit of the annual conference.”

In a concurring opinion, five members of the Judicial Council expressed concern about the closure process, believing the Book of Discipline section contains “an unlawful delegation of authority that circumvents the annual conference’s authority” because it grants “sole discretion authority” to a conference’s “board of trustees to dispose of a local church’s property before the annual conference members approve the closure.”

“Therefore, unless ¶ 2549.4(b)’s process regarding the disposal of local church property is carried out in the sequence of a closure determination, followed by the annual conference members’ approval of the closure, and only then disposal of property in accordance with annual conference policy, we believe the process may be unconstitutional and void as applied,” they added.

In response to the ruling, Escobedo-Frank wrote in a letter to the conference on Wednesday that she is “grateful” for the Judicial Council’s “careful consideration and for the processes of accountability that guide all of us, including me as your bishop.”

“When a church closes, there is sadness,” wrote Escobedo-Frank. “We honor those memories and the faithful people who have been part of La Trinidad’s long history.”

La Trinidad has since been replaced by a new Los Angeles-based ministry called Nueva Esperanza (New Hope), led by the Rev. Ruben Esponda.

"It is a name chosen by the people of this new worshiping community, including some who were part of La Trinidad and others who are joining in this new beginning," the bishop wrote.

“I am grateful for the people of Nueva Esperanza, for Rev. Esponda and for all those who have faithfully worked to ensure that United Methodist ministry continues in East Los Angeles,” she added. “My prayer is that we will continue moving forward together, with open hearts to see what God is doing among us today. There is much to be hopeful about, and there is much work still to do.”

A small congregation that had existed in the Los Angeles area for generations, La Trinidad agreed in 2023 to lease its property to help create an affordable-housing development for seniors.

The lease deal would allow the congregation to keep a worship space at the property and would give the church about $3.3 million, according to UM News.

However, over time, the conference became concerned about how the church was handling the funds and about the congregation’s decline to an average worship attendance of 10 people.

According to the conference, the church did not approve the salary and benefits of a new pastor last year and was limiting some elected church members’ involvement in decision-making.

A legal battle also ensued between church members and the conference over the final $3.1 million lease payment. The conference decided earlier this year to close the church.

The conference has recovered about $2.8 million of the payment so far, UM News reported, and the money is being used to support local Hispanic ministries and fund Nueva Esperanza.

Follow Michael Gryboski on Twitter or Facebook

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.