Latino voters wanted to vote GOP. ICE changed their minds.

The loss of Republican control of Congress did not have to happen.
Many people tried to tell the party that conservative, church-going Hispanic voters represented an important piece of the margin of victory for the midterm congressional races and that the only thing they needed to do to secure Hispanic votes was to recognize their value and have mercy on their families.
Unlike most ethnic minority communities in America, about half of Latino voters hold conservative or traditional values and would prefer to vote Republican. In the 2024 election, 47% of them voted for President Trump, favoring the traditional values of the Republican platform over progressive values. Even more Latinos would have voted for Trump in 2024 if he had announced a commitment to immigration reform that would have supported a plan to redeem Dreamers and hard-working, tax-paying, otherwise law-abiding illegal immigrants.
According to CNN exit polling, Latinos voted 69% for Democrats this November. To have won the Hispanic vote, Republicans did not have to stop controlling the border or deporting violent criminals or even reducing student visas and H1B visas. What they had to do was, at least, commit to reforming the law in a way that would stop dividing mixed-status families, authorize green cards for Dreamers, and consolidate America’s current manual-labor force. Employers (as represented by the American Business Immigration Coalition) had begged for years for a solution to their critical labor needs. If only Republicans had supported the needs of America’s businesses — traditionally not a hard reach for the GOP — they might have kept a Republican majority in Congress.
All over the country this fall, we heard from Latino voters who wanted to support Republican candidates but were choosing not to do so in this election because of the many overreaches of ICE and the administration’s refusal to protect their families from needless separation. If biblical values mattered on pro-life questions, traditional morality, religious freedom, support for Israel and opposition to antisemitism — things Latino conservative voters support — why couldn’t mercy and redemption apply to their families when the economy was pleading for the same? A reasonable plan to punish illegal entry while rehabilitating immigrants has sat on the docket now for years.
But other voices prevailed. Republicans listened to those who insisted on a hard line against unauthorized immigrants in order to gin up support among the MAGA base, people who were never going to vote for the Democrats anyway. And so, Republicans lost Congress, and President Trump may face a 24/7 impeachment circus for the next 24 months.
This disastrous outcome for Republicans does not have to lead to future debacles. President Trump and the lame-duck Republican Congress can take steps in the weeks to come that would create a generational win, securing the loyalty of America’s largest minority population for many years to come. They just have to put key immigration reform provisions in the appropriations bill that has to pass when the current continuing resolution expires on December 11, codifying in law current border control policies while also securing the livelihoods of millions of immigrants and the unity of most mixed-status families. They have a credible plan in front of them, and with President Trump’s support, they can get the reform done before this present Congress expires.
Getting this reform accomplished would place a pearl in President Trump’s legacy. It would enhance affordability (the bête noire that beat Republicans in the election), help restore a Republican majority in Congress in 2028, and ensure a Republican successor in the White House after President Trump leaves office. Most importantly, it would make a start toward building a new coalition to protect America from the Democratic Socialists and their plans. But if the Republican Party refuses to make itself the natural home for Hispanic voters, it will end up as a self-inflicted wound.
It is time now — during the Lame Duck session — for Republican lawmakers to fix the immigration crisis, make a deal with Congressional Democrats, and put an end to this long nightmare of illegal immigration and illegal employment. It’s time to re-establish the rule of law, heal the divide in the country, and preserve the hardworking immigrants who have contributed so much to America’s greatness.
Joseph Castleberry is the author of The New Pilgrims: How Immigrants are Renewing America’s Faith and Values and serves as Vice President for Government Relations for the National Hispanic Christian Leadership Conference.





