Highland Park Methodist Church asks court to block UMC conference from using its former name
Quick Summary
- Highland Park Methodist Church seeks a court order barring a UMC conference from using its old name, "Highland Park United Methodist Church."
- Members voted overwhelmingly to leave the UMC in October. The Texas Horizon Conference called the vote invalid and named the Rev. Andy Lewis pastor of the church.
- The church says the conference is holding services under its old name at a different location and confusing members and donors.

Highland Park Methodist Church has asked a court to stop the United Methodist Church's regional conference in Texas from using the name the Dallas congregation carried before it recently voted to leave the denomination amid a lawsuit over its 2022 governance changes.
In its request for a temporary restraining order, the church says the name Highland Park United Methodist Church, or HPUMC, belongs to it after more than 50 years of use and accuses the UMC's Horizon Texas Conference of infringing on that name by holding services under the same name, FOX 4 reported.
The church argues that members and donors have been unsure which of the two churches' services they attended.
The congregation voted last month to leave the UMC, dropped "United" from its name and now holds services as Highland Park Methodist Church in its own building at Hillcrest Road and Mockingbird Lane.
The denomination's regional body says the congregation's vote to leave the UMC is invalid, and it has continued holding services under the old name, Highland Park United Methodist Church, at University Park United Methodist Church, a separate congregation.
Highland Park's leaders announced that 90.35% of the 4,775 ballots cast by its members favored leaving the denomination. Highland Park's Church Council set December 1, 2026, as its target for finishing the work needed to complete the split.
The Horizon Texas Conference rejected the vote as illegitimate. Last month, Bishop Ruben Saenz Jr. named the Rev. Andy Lewis as pastor of the church and moved its senior minister, the Rev. Matt Tuggle, to other duties.
Highland Park's Church Council called the appointment a "retaliatory move" and stated that Tuggle would remain its senior minister and continue leading Sunday services. In a statement to KERA, a public broadcaster in Dallas, the council wrote that "the bishop's declaration changes nothing for us."
Saenz announced that Lewis and members loyal to the denomination would meet at University Park United Methodist Church for now, while the court case over Highland Park's governance and property goes on.
The bishop stated that the arrangement was meant "to avoid unnecessary conflict while these matters are resolved." University Park, an LGBT-affirming congregation in the denomination, had asked Highland Park members to join Lewis for worship on Nov. 1.
The vote to leave grew out of a legal battle that began in August, when the conference sued the church in Dallas County District Court. The suit argued that the church "appears to be attempting to unilaterally sever" its ties to the denomination.
Church leaders contend that trust between the two sides has broken down. A non-jury trial is set for October 2027, and the church's leaders say they are confident in their legal position.
The complaint focused on a restated certificate of formation that Highland Park's leaders filed in November 2022, which, under Texas law, updated the church's original incorporation charter. It alleged that amended bylaws stripped out every mention of the denomination and ended members' rights to take part in church affairs and to help decide its denomination. Under those bylaws, the complaint added, the Church Council would pick its own members and answer to no one else.
In a video message to members on Aug. 26, Saenz expressed grief over the situation and argued the suit was necessary.
Highland Park responded in September, filing a response and counterclaim arguing that Texas law allowed the 2022 changes and seeking dismissal of the case. Its leaders also cited the church's full participation in the denomination since then, including yearly payments to the conference, after over 7,000 churches quit in 2023 amid a split over LGBT issues.
Before an October town hall, Tuggle and two former senior ministers of the church argued in a statement that the conference knew when the council structure won approval in 1998, and that the 2022 bylaws kept the church in the denomination at a time when over 7,600 churches left. They added that the conference knew of the 2022 changes, helped enact them and raised no concerns until October 2025.
About 800 people attended the town hall, where several council members accused conference leaders of mistreating the church's pastors and staff only for amending its bylaws. On Oct. 15, the council voted unanimously for a churchwide ballot and recommended that members approve leaving.
Highland Park, founded in 1916 as University Church, has ranked among the denomination's largest congregations. UMData, the denomination's online statistics database, listed about 15,000 members in 2024, with average weekly attendance above 4,000 and income above $22 million.
Former President George W. Bush attends services there and has voiced his support for Pastor Tuggle and the congregation amid the legal battle.





