Maine school board can’t deny lease to church over conservative theological beliefs: court

A Maine school board cannot deny a lease to a church seeking to meet in a public school because of the church’s conservative social views, a federal judge has ruled.
Chief U.S. District Judge Lance Walker of the District of Maine issued a decision and order on Friday in the case of The Pines Church and Matt Gioia v. Hermon School Department.
The Pines Church of Bangor applied for a lease at a high school in Hermon, but the school board rejected its application after asking about the church’s positions on issues such as same-sex marriage and abortion.
Walker, a Trump appointee, wrote that “if a public school’s facilities are available for public use, a religious organization cannot be denied access to those facilities because it is a religious organization.”
He concluded that a majority of the school board showed “bad motive” when rejecting the church’s application and thus “violated the Plaintiffs’ rights under the First Amendment.” He criticized one board member's "intrusive questions" that "expressed viewpoint related concerns towards Plaintiffs."
“Defendant’s treatment and denial of the Church’s application for a year-long lease violated the Plaintiffs’ rights under the First Amendment of the United States Constitution and Maine’s public accommodations law,” Walker ruled.
Bob Tyler, president of Advocates for Faith & Freedom, the religious liberty law firm that represented the church, celebrated the ruling in an emailed statement.
“This ruling affirms a fundamental principle: when public schools open their facilities to community groups such as sports teams, scouts, and recreation programs, they cannot exclude churches simply because of their faith,” Tyler said.
“The court saw through pretextual concerns about staffing, capacity, and logistics and correctly identified the real motive — hostility to the Church’s religious viewpoint. The Constitution demands neutrality, and today the court enforced it.”
Pastor Matt Gioia founded The Pines Church in 2021, initially meeting at a movie theater in Orono, Maine. As his congregation grew, he sought a larger space for a one-year lease.
The school board denied the lease after members questioned Gioia about the church’s views on LGBT issues and abortion access.
In May 2023, the church sued Hermon school officials, accusing them of violating the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Maine’s public accommodations laws.
“We are understandably disappointed with the process in which we had to go through, but we are not discouraged,” Gioia said in a statement released in 2023.
“We have seen the Lord move through our church and grow our community so much since our founding. We are hopeful that we will be able to continue our worship and fellowship without discrimination.”





