SD Supreme Court finds lower court erred in settling $300K gift dispute between church, pastor

Wirestock/iStock
Wirestock/iStock

The South Dakota Supreme Court has ruled that a circuit court judge erred when he awarded a church money that one of its former pastors said was a personal gift, without first resolving the pastor’s fraud claim at trial. The donor, who gave the pastor a $300,000 check, stated in an affidavit that the money was meant for the pastor personally.

In a unanimous 16-page opinion written by Justice Mark E. Salter and filed on Nov. 10, the court, which also includes Chief Justice Steven R. Jensen and Justices Patricia J. DeVaney, Scott P. Myren and Robert Gusinsky, reversed First Judicial Circuit Court Judge Patrick T. Smith’s summary judgment in favor of Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida, Inc., whose main parish is in Columbus, Nebraska.

Nohemy Herrera and her husband, Francisco Herrera, formed the church in 2009, and Nohemy serves as its president and lead pastor. The dispute stems from monetary gifts made to the church in the spring of 2022.

According to court documents, Columbus parish member Alex Cooper Vasquez received a monetary settlement for a work injury and met with Nohemy to discuss his desire to make a monetary gift, or gifts. The meeting took place before a church-sponsored event, which the parties referred to as a “campaign,” held in Columbus over the last weekend in April 2022.

At the time, the church also had two other satellite campuses in Yankton and Mitchell. Pastor Mario Torres moved from Columbus to Mitchell to start and lead the satellite parish while Pastor Daniel Cabrerra led the Yankton parish under the direction of Nohemy Herrera, who also served as lead pastor of the church she co-founded in 2009.

At the start of the campaign weekend in April, Torres alleges that he met with Nohemy, who told him that Vasquez would be providing him with a donation to the church. He said Nohemy told him the church would buy him a car and pay him $350 per week. She also explained that the church would buy a van for Cabrerra.  

Over the weekend of the church event, Vasquez wrote three checks for $300,000 each, dated May 2, 2022. He made one check payable to “Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida” and gave it to Nohemy with the word “tithe” written in the memo line.

For the other two checks, Vasquez left the “pay to the order of” line blank and wrote “mission” on the memo line. He placed each check in a separate, sealed envelope and gave one to Cabrerra and the other to Torres.

“Vasquez did not discuss the check with Torres that night, and aside from the check itself, Vasquez did not explain his intent, at least at the time,” the opinion states.

Torres gave his check to Nohemy, who wrote “Iglesia Pentecostal Fuente De Vida Inc.” on the payee line. She did the same with the check Vasquez gave to Cabrerra. The day after the campaign, the checks were deposited in individual accounts for the Yankton and Mitchell parishes at First Dakota National Bank.

Soon after, several checks were written from the Mitchell parish’s account. Two checks totaling $32,000 were written to the Columbus parish. A third was written to Torres for $25,000. Torres, who was a signatory on the account, signed all three checks. Nohemy also began paying Torres his weekly $350 stipend from the Mitchell account.

Torres states that he only later learned from Vasquez that the $300,000 check he was given was a personal gift and not a donation to the church.

“Torres claims that sometime later, Vasquez informed him that the check he had given him after the campaign was meant for Torres, himself, and not a donation to the Mitchell parish. In his deposition testimony, Vasquez explained that he advised Torres that he could take the money out of the Mitchell parish’s account and transfer it to his personal account,” the opinion states.

When Torres transferred $223,000 from the Mitchell parish’s account into his personal account at First Dakota on July 13, 2022, the church reported the transfer as unauthorized and the bank froze the money, setting off the dispute.

“Torres refused to return the $223,000 to the Church, insisting the money was a personal gift. The Church sued Torres for conversion and breach of fiduciary duty,” the opinion explains.

Torres counterclaimed for conversion and fraud, and the church moved for summary judgment on its own claims and on Torres’ counterclaims. Circuit Court Judge Smith sided with the church.

“The circuit court granted the Church’s motion over Torres’ opposition. In its written decision, the court made a ‘finding’ that ‘[a]ll monies in [the Mitchell parish’s] account belonged to the Church or its parish.’ The court also concluded that ‘[a] blank check is not an assignment of funds and is not sufficient delivery of a gift of money.’ Based upon its decision, the court awarded the Church $81,994.86 in prejudgment interest,” the opinion states.

In arguing that the circuit court erred, Torres highlighted an affidavit from Vasquez stating that the church’s founders were told the $300,000 checks handed to the satellite pastors were meant as personal gifts.

“Nohemy and Fra[n]cisco Herrera knew that the checks I delivered to Mario and Daniel were for Mario and Daniel personally. I had specifically told them this prior to writing the checks. Nohemy and Fra[n]cisco Herrera deceived Mario Torres into believing that the check I gave to him on May 2, 2022, . . . was for the Church,” Vasquez states in his affidavit.

“Had it been my intent to donate $900,000 to the Church . . ., I would have written only one check. Instead, I wrote three separate checks. The $300,000 check that I delivered to Mario Torres was for Mario Torres personally.”

While the circuit court correctly determined that the check Vasquez gave to Torres was not a completed gift because the payee line was left blank, the South Dakota Supreme Court justices said the evidence presented did not support its summary judgment in favor of the church.

“The ultimate question of the parties’ relative interests in what are now the negotiated funds from Vasquez implicates disputed issues of material fact that can only be resolved by determining Torres’ fraud claim,” the justices stated. “The court erred when it granted the Church’s motion for summary judgment. We reverse and remand for further proceedings.”

The court also reversed the $81,994.86 prejudgment interest award. While the high court rejected Torres’ argument that civil courts lack jurisdiction over the church’s breach of fiduciary duty claim under the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, finding the case involves “purely secular questions concerning the right to possess the money held in the Church’s bank account,” it reversed the lower court’s ruling on that claim as well, since it depends on the outcome of Torres’s fraud claim.

Contact: leonardo.blair@christianpost.com Follow Leonardo Blair on Twitter: @leoblair Follow Leonardo Blair on Facebook: LeoBlairChristianPost

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.