Calif. claims victory in settlement with bakery over refusal to create same-sex wedding cake
State cheers 'brave' lesbian couple after Christian business owner 'backs down'

A California bakery has reached a settlement with the state in a long-running legal dispute over the bakery’s refusal to sell a cake to a lesbian couple for their wedding.
Cathy Miller, owner of Tastries Bakery in Bakersfield, has agreed to a mutual settlement with the California Civil Rights Department in a case that began in 2017, when Tastries refused to sell a generic, multipurpose white cake to Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio, a lesbian couple who wanted it for their wedding.
After the bakery cited its policy against selling cakes for celebrations of same-sex unions, the women filed a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department, which investigated and determined there was cause to believe the bakery had violated the state’s Unruh Civil Rights Act. That law requires businesses such as bakeries, restaurants and retail stores to offer full and equal access to goods and services without discriminating based on protected characteristics, including sexual orientation.
After the department sued Tastries Bakery in 2018, a Kern County Superior Court judge ruled in favor of the bakery in late 2022. The state appealed, and the Fifth District Court of Appeal ruled for the Civil Rights Department in February 2025. Both the California Supreme Court and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to review the appellate decision later that year.
Under the settlement, the bakery will provide non-customized products, including cakes, to all customers regardless of sexual orientation or other protected characteristics. It will also attend annual civil rights training provided by the department, post notices about state civil rights protections, notify the department of any discrimination complaints, report annually on compliance and pay $12,000 in damages and fees.
In its press release announcing the settlement, the Civil Rights Department positioned the settlement as a legal victory in which Tastries Bakery “backs down” from its refusal to customize cakes and other pastries for same-sex couples.
“In California, we don’t turn people away because of who they love or where they come from,” Civil Rights Department Director Kevin Kish said. “Whether it’s a bakery, restaurant, coffee shop, or grocery store, we are all entitled to full and equal services at businesses in our state. When people like Eileen and Mireya Rodriguez-Del Rio are brave enough to speak out for their rights, it can often help strengthen those protections for everyone. This settlement shows that California is open to business for all.”
In a Nov. 17 statement posted on social media, Miller emphasized that the bakery has always welcomed all customers and will continue offering high-quality products and creative designs. “Under this settlement, we affirm that all generic, multipurpose products will be available to everyone that comes to Tastries on an equal basis,” she said. “We are pleased that this agreement allows us to continue operating Tastries in a way that does not violate our faith and values.”
In contrast with the Civil Rights Department, Miller framed the dispute in terms of religious liberty and personal conscience rather than the specific product. “For me, this case has never been about the cake. It has always been about conscience and the freedom of business owners to operate in line with their faith,” she said. “I always seek to serve everyone, but I just can’t create every message.”
She expressed gratitude to the courts for addressing complex legal questions and pledged to follow their guidance. Miller also thanked supporters who stood with the bakery and prayed for it during the lengthy case. “To everyone who has stood with us and prayed for us: thank you for believing in us; it is not possible to express what your love and support has meant to me and the Tastries team. Now we carry on because our hope rests in God.”
While the Supreme Court declined to hear Miller’s case, an August 2025 petition submitted by attorneys on behalf of Miller said the bakery owner received “hundreds” of explicit messages, including one that said “Jesus himself will condemn you to Hell” and another which claimed, “Other religions hate Christians because they are bigoted, sexist and racist.”
The case is one of several civil rights cases involving bakeries and religious freedom, perhaps most notable of which came in 2018, when the Supreme Court sided with Colorado Christian baker Jack Phillips, who faced hostility from the Colorado Civil Rights Commission for refusing to make a custom same-sex wedding cake in 2012, when same-sex marriage wasn't legal in the state or nationally.
The court found Phillips' use of artistic abilities to make a wedding cake carries a "significant First Amendment speech component and implicates his deep and sincere religious beliefs."
Ian M. Giatti is a reporter for The Christian Post. He can be reached at: ian.giatti@christianpost.com.





