Last October, evangelicalism was rocked by the launch of ChurchClarity.org, an organization that reports churches' LGBTQ+ policies and rates congregations based on their level of clarity. The website angered Christians on both sides of the issue. Some conservatives attacked the CC's liberal leadership, while some progressives claimed that labeling churches undermined progress.
Nevertheless, Church Clarity persisted.
Over the past two months, CC published scores for 500 congregations and have 700 more in the pipeline. But today, they announced their most significant accomplishment to date: a detailed analysis of America's 100 largest churches. Using Outreach Magazine's popular annual list, CC's staff uncovered three explosive insights about America's megachurches.
- None of America's 100 largest churches are LGBTQ-affirming.
While progressive Christians often claim that same-sex issues have largely been settled, America's megachurches have apparently not received the memo. None of them have policies affirming same-sex people and relationships. This staggering statistic will doubtlessly provide firepower to conservative Christians who claim that LGBTQ+ affirmation is a slippery slope to liberalism and a congregation killer.
And yet the data also provides progressives a counterargument. According to CC's analysis, a paltry 35 percent of these megachurches have clear LGBTQ+ policies, and 54 percent actually hide their positions (e.g. sermons and blogposts) deep inside their websites. This seems to indicate that many non-affirming megachurches are not as boldly opposed as one might assume, and some of these large congregations may be currently reconsidering their positions and policies.
- 93 percent of America's 100 largest churches are led by a white pastor.
Only 7 out of 100 of the churches on Outreach'slist are led by a person of color. For context, people of color comprise nearly 40 percent of the American population. So despite the Christian calls to diversity, equality, and justice, America's megachurches are still lagging in the race department. These churches may preach a gospel of inclusion, but they disproportionately prefer white men for their top leadership positions.
- Only 1 of America's 100 largest churches has a female pastor.
Female pastors are on the rise in America, but not so for the largest megachurches. Only 1 of the 100 largest churches on Outreach's list cites a female pastor. Faith Church in West Palm Beach, Florida holds this honor, yet even that congregation lists Nicole Crank as a co-pastor alongside her husband, David.
Given that 8 percent of Fortune 100 companies are led by women CEOs, one might say that secular companies are more gender-inclusive than spiritual communities in America. In October of 2018, Heather Larson will join the list as she assumes the role of lead pastor at Willow Creek Community Church outside of Chicago. Even still, this statistic is surely deflating for those Christians who advocate for women in church leadership.
The Outreach Magazine list is conducted in coordination with LifeWay Research, the public polling arm of the Southern Baptist Convention. Since congregations must disclose their numbers in order to be list, it is not fully comprehensive. However, the listed churches still represent more than 1.1 million American Christians.
With the New Year looming, Church Clarity's leaders claim that their analysis arrives not a moment too soon.
"Part of the reason we chose to release this now is because the New Year is a time when people decide to reengage with religion by attending church," said Church Clarity's co-founder Tim Schraeder. "As people of faith commit to new resolutions, we wanted to set them up for success by helping them make the most informed decision."
Church Clarity's leaders added that their decision to analyze race and gender in addition to sexuality also hints at the organization's expanding mission. In the future, they plan to also report on race and gender inclusion among church leadership. So this is not the first time Church Clarity has created a stir, and neither will it be the last.
Originally published at Red Letter Christians. The goal of Red Letter Christians is simple: To take Jesus seriously by endeavoring to live out His radical, counter-cultural teachings as set forth in Scripture, and especially embracing the lifestyle prescribed in the Sermon on the Mount. Find them online at https://www.redletterchristians.org/