CP VOICES

Engaging views and analysis from outside contributors on the issues affecting society and faith today.

CP VOICES do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s).

Should Christian ministries have to hire non-Christians?

iStock/skynesher
iStock/skynesher

“The proof,” folks used to say, “is in the pudding.”

The ultimate measure of the quality of anything — a good dessert or a good ministry — is whether it accomplishes what it was designed to do. A pudding tastes good, or it doesn’t. A ministry is accomplishing good things for the people of its community — doing work generally acknowledged to be making a positive impact on the lives of all involved — or it isn’t.

The Yakima Union Gospel Mission, by common consent, is doing what it was created to do almost 100 years ago: reaching out, in the name of Christ, to the homeless and hurting of central Washington. So, why is it having to defend itself before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit, which could decide its case any day now?

Virtually everyone agrees that the mission, like mine in Columbus, Ohio, does good work: serving people of all backgrounds and beliefs, helping many to find renewed hope, purpose, and direction for their lives. To ensure those happy results, the ministry’s leaders make a point of hiring only people who share their religious convictions and faith.

That’s pretty much common sense — it’s why PETA, for instance, hires animal lovers — but it’s a philosophy that state officials have begun taking exception to. In 2021, the state Supreme Court gutted a 72-year-old statute protecting religious ministries, rewriting it to force them to hire people who reject their faith. Officials then threatened to enforce the rewritten law against religious ministries like YUGM.

YUGM sued, and early this year, a unanimous three-judge 9th Circuit panel ruled in favor of the mission’s First Amendment right to hire those who share its religious beliefs. Washington asked the 9th Circuit to hear the case en banc, and the court did so. The full bench should affirm the earlier ruling.

That decision will be of substantial interest to other Christian organizations being compelled to hire non-Christians — including the ministry I lead.

Gracehaven was created in 2008 to alert youth and families to the dangers of sex trafficking and to offer clinical and support services to those emerging from it. We provide that help through a variety of compassionate programs, including state-licensed therapeutic group homes.

As a Christian ministry like YUGM, our team is an expression of our collective faith. We also offer spiritual options: Bible studies, prayer, and rides to local church services. Through compassionate words, caring action, and a loving spirit, we seek to present these girls with a new, hopeful, and healing perspective on their lives and future.

Like YUGM, we take care to hire conscientious Christians for every position. That’s been a crucial element of our ministry from its beginning, and we believe it’s been essential to our successful interaction with hundreds of teens across these 18 years.

Many have been placed in Gracehaven through the Montgomery County foster-care system; clearly, they believe that what we offer works and has made a life-changing impact on the fragile, broken lives they entrust to our care.

Two years ago, though, that solid partnership hit a major impasse. County officials took an unexpected exception to our commitment to hiring only Christians to serve in our group homes. They refused to re-contract with us unless we stopped hiring staff based on our beliefs.

Curious, given that we’d never made any secret of our hiring policy. We acknowledge that staff who don’t share our faith may be capable of offering compassionate counsel and care to survivors of sex trafficking. However, they don’t offer the kind of grace, love, or Christian perspective we deem critical to our work’s success. Like YUGM, we believe our team's commitment to Christian beliefs should not negate our participation in efforts to help these hurting teens.

Faced with the choice of forfeiting our identity as a ministry or forgoing the opportunity to serve the young women of Montgomery County, we enlisted the help of Alliance Defending Freedom to sue the county in federal court. The judge who heard our case ruled that Gracehaven would be eligible for county referrals while our case progressed; county officials later acquiesced to our position and agreed to settle the case.

That settlement makes possible the ongoing work of Gracehaven but also affirms the fact that public officials — in Ohio, Washington, and across the country — can cooperate with service-minded Christians to accomplish common goals. A good decision in the YUGM case could help shore up legal precedent for protecting the freedoms of ministries, like mine and others, in the future.

Scott Arnold is executive director of Gracehaven in Columbus, Ohio.

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.

Most Popular

More In Opinion