Christian counties swung hardest towards Dems in 2026, study finds
Quick Summary
- The most Christian counties moved 20.5 points toward Democrats in 2026, according to a new study from Evangelicals for a Better Future.
- Starr County, Texas, a mostly Catholic area, saw the biggest swing nationwide: 71.8 points.
- Conservative leader cites low Christian turnout and unkept GOP promises on affordability.

Counties with the highest percentages of Christians swung hardest to Democrats in the 2026 midterm elections, with political observers on both sides of the aisle criticizing Republicans' broken promises and messaging that ignored the struggles of families.
A study by the progressive political organization Evangelicals for a Better Future compared 2024 presidential results with 2026 midterm results by county, finding that nearly every county moved left over the past two years, with the exceptions located primarily in Maine, Illinois, South Dakota and Florida.
The 2026 midterm elections put Democrats in control of the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate during the final two years of President Donald Trump's term. Unfinalized results show Democrats have picked up at least 42 seats in the U.S. House and at least eight seats in the U.S. Senate.
The study's main takeaway is that the counties with the highest percentage of Christians swung 20.5 percentage points to Democrats collectively, while the least Christian counties moved 9.4 percentage points to the political left.
In most cases, the Democratic margin in the 2024 presidential election was compared with the margin of the Democratic U.S. Senate candidate in 2026. In states without a U.S. Senate race, the 2024 presidential margin was compared with the margin in the U.S. House race.
“This study demonstrates that Christian voters are increasingly swing voters,” Lee Scott, director of Evangelicals for a Better Future and a Presbyterian pastor, said in a statement shared with The Christian Post. “This isn’t about a re-emergence of the Christian left. It’s about the emergence of a truly Christian middle.”
Evangelicals for a Better Future contends the shift points to several factors, including Republican voters staying home, others voting for Democrats and "Democratic-leaning evangelicals turning out after sitting out in 2024."
The organization points specifically to regions of the Bible Belt, such as Mississippi County, Arkansas, which moved 24.7 points toward Democrats. A 23.9-point shift was seen in Bristol, Virginia, and Anderson County, South Carolina, which the group calls "a striking erosion of Republican margins in evangelical strongholds."
Scott contends that Christian voters "aren’t beholden to a single party, and they sent a clear message rejecting the heresy of Christian nationalism.” He claimed that the results show “a clear sign that any party that takes their vote for granted or ignores the struggles of the families in their pews, does so at its own risk.”
While counties with the largest percentages of born-again or Evangelical voters may have swung left in 2026, exit polls in both 2024 and 2026 showed that 82% of white Evangelical Christians backed Republicans, while 17% supported Democrats. However, white Evangelicals or born-again voters made up only 17% of the electorate in 2026, down from 23% in 2024.
Among Protestants or other Christians, 63% voted for Trump in 2024, compared with 59% who supported Republicans in 2026. That group made up 43% of the electorate in 2024 and 40% in 2026. Trump received 59% of the Catholic vote in 2024, while 51% of Catholics voted for Democrats in 2026. The Catholic share of the electorate also shrank, from 21% to 20%.
By contrast, the nonreligious share of the electorate grew from 24% in 2024 to 27% in 2026. The overwhelming majority of nonreligious voters backed Democrats in both 2024 (71%) and 2026 (79%).
Starr County, Texas, swung hardest toward Democrats nationwide. The overwhelmingly Catholic county backed Trump by 16 percentage points in 2024 but supported Democrat James Talarico by more than 55 points in the 2026 U.S. Senate race. Eight of the 10 counties with the largest swings toward Democrats were majority-Catholic or plurality-Catholic counties in South Texas, with swings ranging from 71.8 percentage points in Starr County to 44.3 points in plurality-Catholic Cameron County.
Conservative grassroots leader Mark Meckler, president and founder of the Convention of States Project, pushed back on the notion that Christians, and Evangelicals in particular, moved to the left, suggesting the result was caused by low voter turnout among conservative Christians fed up with broken political promises on affordability and inflation.
“It’s important to remember that most Christians didn’t vote,” he said. “I’m an Evangelical Christian. We find it frustrating that generally 30 to 34% of Evangelical Christians vote.”
Low turnout among Evangelical and Christian voters has been a major concern in conservative circles in recent years.
At a panel at the 2024 Conservative Political Action Conference, Chad Connelly, CEO of the advocacy group Faith Wins, estimated that between 30 million and 45 million Evangelical Christians nationwide do not vote.
Meckler said Evangelicals and Christians “didn’t turn out because Republicans didn’t do what they promised to do.” He told CP that Republicans failed to follow through on their promises to “go after affordability” and identified Trump’s tariffs as a major factor in the election results.
“The tariffs ultimately are always passed on to consumers in the price of basic goods and services, and so that happened. And so that increased prices. The war in Iran clearly increased the price of oil, which increases the price of gas, which keeps inflation up," Meckler said.
"When you increase the price of gas and energy, the price of everything goes up because everything utilizes fuel in one way or another through production or transportation.”
Meckler criticized the White House’s pre-election messaging based on “frivolous things, which Americans aren’t interested in when they’re hurting.” He criticized the suggestion that New Mexico be renamed New America and his push to rename Lake Ontario Lake America as examples of misplaced priorities.
“You can get away with that stuff if Americans are doing well," he said. "While the economy, broadly speaking, is very healthy, average Americans are not doing well, and Republicans forgot about that, and they didn’t message around that, and they didn’t fulfill their promises around that,” he added.
Ryan Foley is a reporter for The Christian Post. He can be reached at: ryan.foley@christianpost.com




