Minnesota fathers sue state for barring religious education from K-12 tax benefit

Quick Summary

  • Pastor Nathan Colestock and Joseph Osburn filed a complaint Monday in the Minnesota Tax Court.
  • State law bars tuition aid when the education is religious.
  • Alliance Defending Freedom represents the men and cites their First Amendment rights.

An artificial intelligence-powered tool created this summary based on the source article. The summary has undergone review and verification by an editor.

iStock/monkeybusinessimages
iStock/monkeybusinessimages

Two Christian fathers have sued a Minnesota state official for denying them access to a public financial aid program that other parents are eligible for because the education they want to give their children is religious in nature.

Nathan Colestock, a pastor and father of four children, and Joseph Osburn, the father of six children, filed a complaint Monday in the State of Minnesota Tax Court, Regular Division.

Paul Marquart, commissioner of revenue for the State of Minnesota, is the named defendant in the lawsuit and is being sued in his official capacity.

According to the complaint, both fathers believe “God calls them to teach their children to know and love Him” and “choose Christian curricula, materials, academies, and co-ops that teach every lesson through that lens.”

Three of the Osburns' children are enrolled at Knox Classical Academy, with homeschooling supplementing their education on the other two days of the week. The family participates in a Christian homeschool co-op.

Colestock's two oldest children attend Valor Classical Academy three days a week. Colestock is also the part-time head of Valor Classical Academy. Like the Osburns, Colestock's children attend Valor Classical Academy three times per week and are homeschooled on the remaining days. 

The state allows parents to get financial aid for their children’s education through Minnesota’s K-12 Education Subtraction and Credit, which offsets the costs of things like textbooks and tutoring.

However, two Minnesota statutes — Minn. Stat. § 290.0674, subd. 1a(b)(2), and Minn. Stat. § 290.0132, subd. 4 — prevent parents from receiving that assistance if the education is religious.

“Because of that catch, Minnesota makes these fathers choose between their faith and the benefit. To receive it, they must strip their faith from their children’s lessons. To remain faithful, they must go without. Their faith forbids the first option. So they go without,” reads the complaint.

“By excluding religious instruction from these generally available tax benefits, Minnesota violates these fathers’ rights under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, the Minnesota Constitution’s guarantee of freedom of conscience, and the Fourteenth Amendment’s protection of parents’ right to direct the upbringing and education of their children.”

Colestock and Osburn are represented by Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), a conservative legal group that has successfully argued cases before the U.S. Supreme Court.

ADF Senior Counsel Kate Anderson said in a statement Wednesday that parents “have the right to direct how their children are raised and educated,” not the state government.

“Minnesota can’t offer all parents a tax break and then exclude families like the Colestocks and Osburns, who choose to educate their kids fully in line with their faith,” Anderson said.

“We’re urging the court to uphold the fundamental right of Minnesota families to choose Christian education for their kids while receiving much-needed financial help from the state — aid that is available to all other families.”

In 2020, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue that Montana parents could use a public scholarship program to send their children to religious schools.

Follow Michael Gryboski on Twitter or Facebook

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.

Most Popular