Ex-LGBT Christians warn EU ban could criminalize pastoral counseling, personal testimony

Maltese Christian Matthew Grech and other former LGBT Christians urged lawmakers at the European Parliament to oppose a Europe-wide ban on “conversion practices,” arguing that Malta’s law put him on trial for three years over an interview about his own life.
Speakers from the U.K., Hungary and Italy joined Grech at a Brussels meeting this week, organized by Italian European Parliament member Paolo Inselvini with Northern Ireland-based Christian charity Core Issues Trust.
“I spent three years in court for a conversation about my own life,” Grech told the lawmakers, according to a statement provided to The Christian Post by the U.K.-based group Christian Concern, which is supporting his case.
He argued that Malta’s law, meant as a model for Europe, ends with police, prosecutors and judges choosing which personal stories people may tell, and asked lawmakers to keep his experience from becoming law for every European family.
WATCH Matthew Grech share his story of facing prison for sharing his Christian conversion.
Several other speakers told how faith in Jesus, and for some pastoral or clinical help, had changed their feelings and behavior. They warned that loosely written bans could turn personal testimony and church ministry into crimes, and could stop adults from seeking counseling that fits their own beliefs and aims.
They explained that laws often define “conversion practices” so widely that they reach past abuse into everyday talks between a pastor and a churchgoer, a counselor and a client, or a parent and a child.
They argued that coercion and abuse belong under current criminal and safeguarding law, and warned that sweeping new offenses could curb religious liberty, free speech and the right of adults to look for voluntary support.
The Brussels gathering took place as the European Commission got ready to issue a Recommendation in 2027 asking all 27 member states to outlaw “conversion practices.”
Malta passed Europe’s first such ban in 2016.
Grech’s case began with a 2022 interview on the Maltese outlet PMnews Malta. He spoke about giving up a homosexual lifestyle after he became a Christian, about his faith, and about pastoral and professional help for people troubled by unwanted sexual feelings or behavior.
He also mentioned the International Foundation for Counseling and Therapeutic Choice, or IFTCC, a global body that backs freedom of choice in counseling.
Prosecutors charged that the interview was illegal advertising of “conversion practices.”
Grech faced up to five months in jail and a fine of as much as 5,000 euros (about $5,800). After 17 hearings, the Court of Magistrates in Valletta, Malta’s capital, cleared him on March 4.
The court also acquitted the pair of journalists behind the interview, Mario Camilleri and Rita Bonnici, ruling that the broadcast was lawful public debate and personal testimony, according to the Observatory on Intolerance and Discrimination against Christians in Europe.
Malta’s attorney general appealed, and the case returned to court on Oct. 2, 2026. A ruling is due in January 2027.
After his acquittal, Grech spoke of the emotional toll, reputational harm, cost and uncertainty of the case. “Over these past three years, the process itself became the punishment,” he said.
Mike Davidson, of Core Issues Trust, argued that politicians rarely hear from people who found pastoral support or counseling helpful.
His group is pressing the U.K. Parliament at Westminster and the Northern Ireland Assembly at Stormont to listen to such people and protect their access to support. He called Grech’s three-year prosecution for telling his story “outrageous.”
Roger Kiska from Christian Legal Centre, Christian Concern’s legal arm, said such bans clash with human rights. He pointed to the European Convention on Human Rights and said the right to self-fulfillment and to choose how one identifies is at stake.
Andrea Williams, the group’s chief executive, welcomed the acquittal, adding that Grech should not have faced charges at all. She called his case “a stark warning to Europe” about vague laws.
In Britain, Baroness Hilary Cass, who led an independent review of the National Health Service’s gender identity care for young patients, has stopped backing the U.K. bill as now drafted. She warned that its loose wording could have serious effects nobody intended, such as parents being prosecuted for limiting a child’s access to hormones or chest binders.
Christians, free-speech campaigners and senior figures in the Church of England have also opposed the British proposal over its possible effect on routine pastoral work.




