Recommended

CP VOICES

Engaging views and analysis from outside contributors on the issues affecting society and faith today.

CP VOICES do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s).

Trump must end UNICEF's war on international adoption

Family, adoption and kids portrait on beach with mom enjoying USA summer vacation in the sun.
Family, adoption and kids portrait on beach with mom enjoying USA summer vacation in the sun. | iStock/PeopleImages

International adoption has a public relations problem, and the United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) is to blame.  

The public conversation in recent years has been shaped by UNICEF and its ongoing war against international adoption. Just as identity politics has often done, UNICEF has elevated individual experiences and presented them as the norm. It has taken a small minority of worst-case scenarios and portrayed them throughout the international child welfare community as commonplace.  

In reality, the vast majority of U.S. adoptees born in other countries have thrived in America. They've loved living here, and they're grateful to have grown up in their families.  

As president of the largest Evangelical Christian adoption agency in the U.S., I've heard countless stories, both within and beyond our organization, from adoptees who have nothing but gratitude for the opportunity to be adopted into the United States. I've known adoptees who excelled in school, became doctors who have saved lives, and have grown up to become thriving parents themselves. So, what happened? Why have thousands of success stories been ignored?  

The shift began around the turn of the century, when UNICEF began spreading propaganda against intercountry adoption. It was subtle at first and sounded promising. The organization said the goals should be reunification with biological families, kinship care, or domestic adoption. These are all worthy pursuits that I personally support.  

But UNICEF didn't stop there. It began promoting these outcomes above all others, eventually claiming that international adoption should always be a last resort or abandoned altogether. It’s a sweeping statement I’ve heard too many UNICEF officials make. 

Today, UNICEF's website still lists intercountry adoption as a possible outcome for children. To someone outside the child welfare field, it may seem that adoption remains a viable option. But what is written on paper is not what is executed in practice. I've testified alongside UNICEF representatives in Africa and Latin America and attended enough meetings to know that these are empty words.  

The influence of UNICEF and the international child welfare framework surrounding the Hague Convention cannot be overstated. In recent years, countries have begun shuttering their international adoption programs. China, Ethiopia, Guatemala, Nepal and Latvia are just a few examples. Diplomatic issues are often the stated reason, but those issues are reinforced, in large part, by powerful myths about adoption that UNICEF has helped promote.  

This approach has pitted cultures against one another. The message has been that children are better off remaining in their country of origin, regardless of their quality of life. Even if it means growing up in institutions without a loving family. Even if it means struggling with hunger and starvation. Even if it means living without access to proper medical care.  

The campaign has been successful. Last year, 973 children were adopted into the United States. In 2004, at the peak of international adoption, that number was 22,998.  

Make no mistake: this decline is not due to fewer children needing loving families or fewer families willing to provide them. International adoption has plummeted in large part because of UNICEF's political and cultural influence.  

The Trump administration has unwittingly fallen into UNICEF's plan to reduce the number of children adopted internationally. Like so much of the rest of our culture, it has overlooked thousands of successful adoptions that have resulted in far better lives for children from around the world.  

National identity, cultural continuity, and the preservation of birth-family relationships matter. But they should not automatically outweigh a child's need for safety, permanent family care, or essential medical treatment.  

Adoption advocates like me refuse to sit back while a war is waged against international adoption. During National Adoption Month this November, we're challenging our nation to rethink the framework that has surrounded intercountry adoption for decades.  

The United States must answer the question: Why has international adoption plummeted? To do that, we need an immediate, detailed review of our intercountry adoption policies. The Trump administration should focus on three priorities.  

First, we must engage diplomatically with countries that have suspended their programs. We need concrete answers about their motives and a better understanding of the perspectives and barriers that led them to this decision.  

Second, we need transparent reporting about the outcomes of adopted children. We cannot allow ideological bias or shocking outlier stories to drive our policies. Comprehensive, research-based outcomes must guide our decisions.  

Finally, we need streamlined procedures that prioritize safe, loving families for children while maintaining essential safeguards. Oversight in international child welfare and adoption is critical. Without it, corruption and abuse can arise. But we must distinguish between necessary safeguards and unnecessary attitudes and barriers that prevent children from finding loving families.  

While international adoption has fallen out of cultural favor in recent decades, the global need remains great. Unless we change the narrative surrounding international adoption, orphaned children around the world will continue to languish without the families they need.  

We can reclaim lost ground in the battle against international adoption. We can restore intercountry adoption as a legitimate, viable option for children in need. Much to UNICEF's chagrin, that restoration is possible if the United States commits to challenging the assumptions that have shaped modern international adoption policy.

Herbie Newell is president and executive director of Lifeline Children’s Services and author of the book Image Bearers: Shifting from Pro-birth to Pro-life.

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.

Most Popular