Recommended

CP VOICES

Engaging views and analysis from outside contributors on the issues affecting society and faith today.

CP VOICES do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s).

Christian disagreement with feminism has become hatred of women

iStock/Adrian Vidal
iStock/Adrian Vidal

“Feminism is cancer.” Across much of the Right-wing alt media, the podcast scene, and social media, this quip and others like it draw countless likes, reposts, and views, including from professing Christians.

Although I understand some of their objections, much of what passes for a critique of feminism online has morphed into something else: a ferocious, boiling contempt for women as a whole. Worst of all, it winds up bolstering the very thing these critics claim to hate.

I'll be up front about how I think here. As a socially conservative Evangelical, I can't in good conscience accept many feminists' anthropological and metaphysical claims about human nature or who God is. While abusive men in power do indeed create all kinds of problems, I disagree with the way some feminists tend to blame all the world's ills on “the patriarchy.”  I'll also readily acknowledge that women are capable of unmitigated wickedness, and sometimes it can be hard to detect, particularly if they are skilled in the dark, cultic art of manipulation. And I hold that the unborn possess inherent, inviolable dignity that should be reflected in our laws and customs. Regarding third-wave feminism, the variety that promotes porn, prostitution, transgenderism, and other moral scourges as empowering, I see it as an enormous hellscape that I wholly reject. If indeed that's what most people think “feminism” means, I completely understand and agree with the revulsion.

So why does it sound like I'm about to defend something I strongly object to? Because profound disagreement isn't the bulk of the online discourse, which spills over into “real” life. The bulk of it is snarling and unmistakable disdain for women.

To hear many increasingly popular figures in these spaces tell it, feminism, and feminism alone, is the root of all the world's ills. Depending on the intellectual acumen of the talking head, little is said about the differences between its waves and expressions. In fairness, that can be confusing. But much of this discourse consists of cruel barbs hurled at women and dissenting voices, littered with newfangled words like “longhouse” and “gynocracy.” Clips of women behaving obnoxiously on X are almost always met with the label “Karen.” Incubated in these online spaces are destructive attitudes and the cultivation of grievances.

This contempt for women isn't confined to critiquing their vices or the bad behavior of specific individual females, which can be real. It often comes with hashtags and messages pushing to repeal the 19th Amendment, a chauvinist and delusional aim. For this loudmouthed swath of voices on the political right, and even in some churches, anything remotely feminist must be ripped out root and branch.

A serious debate exists about whether earlier waves of feminism, which championed causes that weren't inherently wrong, led to the relational breakdown between the sexes we see all around us. As The Christian Post contributor Kaeley Harms has noted, many who explore that question point to French writer Simone de Beauvoir's line in The Second Sex that “one is not born, but rather becomes, a woman.” None other than Pope Benedict XVI argued in a 2012 speech, just before transgenderism exploded across the West, that this idea helped lay the groundwork for a destructive philosophy of gender and sexuality, the main idea being that if womanhood can be made into a social construction, it can ultimately be made into anything, including a man. I will admit that I think that argument has merit. Feminists will no doubt reply that de Beauvoir was describing the process of how women are socialized, not denying the uniqueness or material reality of the female sex.

This is a layered, substantive topic worth discussing. But what has erupted online, especially on X, in recent years is mostly not that. It is a battle-of-the-sexes rage fest, ungodly and unproductive. Worst of all, many women who, like me, cannot agree with some of feminism's core claims and goals are bearing the brunt of the hostility. And for what? 

When Right-wing, professing Christian men sneer online and in real life at working moms as “boss babes” for punching a clock instead of tending the home, even though many must work in a structurally dysfunctional, K-shaped economy, they are not objecting to feminism.

When they insist that women are unfit for any leadership capacity because they are biologically prone to deception, they are not objecting to feminism.

When they insist that marriage and motherhood are a woman's highest calling (not that there's anything wrong with either) while treating unmarried and childless women as worthless, they are not objecting to feminism.

And when they label women who push back as bitter hags who need to learn their “role” and place, they aren't objecting to feminism. They are wallowing in chauvinistic bilge and proving a point many feminists have made for years.

It was, after all, feminist Andrea Dworkin who wrote in 1983 that Right-wing men treat women as private property and Left-wing men treat them as public property. She had a point. Yes, it was a generalization; not every conservative or liberal man behaves this way. But this dynamic is becoming quite visible online, with entitled Right-wing men effectively demanding servile housewives while libertine leftist men promote scourges like prostitution as a human right.

Indeed, the Left's contempt for women is real, but it is often manipulatively framed as something good. For instance, storied “human rights” groups like Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch increasingly promote “sex work,” and New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports decriminalizing it. Blue states such as New York and Washington have legalized commercial surrogacy in recent years, treating women like breeders, framed as the "right" of LGBT-identified persons and infertile couples to start families. Handmaid's Tale, anyone? Many on the Left also defend the blight of pornography under the guise of civil liberties. Despite notable cultural pushback and legal setbacks, many left-wing men (and women, alas) also continue to pretend not to know what a woman is while championing all things “trans,” an enormous affront to the dignity of actual women, particularly given how males have been legally allowed to invade their private spaces, bathrooms, sports teams, and prisons by merely claiming to be female.

Christians and conservatives had a real chance to counter this abject insanity and degradation and show they take women's well-being seriously. Instead, more and more on the political right and in Christian circles, particularly online, have decided that unbridled fury against feminism and scapegoating women is the prescription. 

They are also ignoring common ground where genuinely good ends could be sought. Feminists are not a monolith. Early feminist efforts sometimes overlapped with historic Christian views, such as British social reformer Josephine Butler's tireless work against state-regulated prostitution. Dworkin herself collaborated with Republicans in the 1980s to combat the pornography industry. One wonders whether today's right-wing rage posters know that, or whether they would ever extend good faith to feminists on issues of mutual concern. By the looks of it, the answer is clearly no.

That is a crying shame, because Christians have a much better Story to tell, and it should be their natural default. Jesus honored women in a world that treated them like cattle, and the early Church followed His lead, which is why women ran toward it. As Louise Perry, author of The Case Against the Sexual Revolution, observed in 2023:

[The Apostle] Paul’s prohibition of (to use the Greek term) porneia — that is, illicit sexual activity, including prostitution — upended an ethical system in which male access to the female body was unquestioned and unquestionable. Whereas the Romans regarded male chastity as profoundly unhealthy, Christians prized it and insisted on it. Early converts were disproportionately female because the Christian valorization of weakness offered obvious benefits to the weaker sex, who could—for the first time — demand sexual continence of men. Feminism is not opposed to Christianity: It is its descendant.

What I see online and in the podcast world could not be further from the noble ethos Perry describes. With the rise of alt media and the dissident-right podcast sphere, the lefty stereotypes about Christian contempt for women — a phenomenon often foreign to many earnest, salt-of-the-earth believers in Jesus — are ringing truer by the hour.

There are legitimate philosophical objections to feminism's core claims, but it's possible to hold and express them without despising women. Many women are watching closely to see whether we know the difference. By many appearances online, we do not.

So, disagree with feminist views as firmly as your conscience demands. I know I do. But if you can't do it without sneering at half of humanity, you aren't defending or upholding anything good.

You're only furthering the very thing you loathe.

Send news tips to: brandon.showalter@christianpost.com Listen to Brandon Showalter's Life in the Kingdom podcast at The Christian Post and edifi app Follow Brandon Showalter on Facebook: BrandonMarkShowalter Follow on Twitter: @BrandonMShow

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.

Most Popular