Recommended

CP VOICES

Engaging views and analysis from outside contributors on the issues affecting society and faith today.

CP VOICES do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s).

The rot on X isn’t fringe anymore. Pastors, wake up.

iStock/Kenneth Cheung
iStock/Kenneth Cheung

You can’t resist what you don’t know exists. And calling what you do know about “fringe,” even if it’s true, won’t make it go away. Unless resisted, fringes gain footholds.

I’m speaking of the moral and spiritual rot that has spread across social media in recent years and now reaches enormous proportions. If you weren’t active on Twitter (now X), you could have dismissed much of it as marginal and tuned it out rather than dignify foolishness. That would have been fair. Or you may not have known about it at all.

It is increasingly common knowledge that younger generations are radicalizing ideologically, along several lines, most notably between young men and women. Many factors are at work. The trend was brewing before COVID-19, but the pandemic was an inflection point, and a rapidly changing media environment, social media and X in particular, has aided and abetted it.

Despite significant worldview differences with Elon Musk, when the world’s first trillionaire bought Twitter, I was cautiously hopeful that debates stifled under previous ownership might finally gain traction.

The old censorship was heavy, and it wasn’t long ago. Reporting we now know was authentic, such as the New York Post’s 2020 story on the Hunter Biden laptop, published just before the election, was systematically suppressed on Twitter and other platforms. More personally, The Christian Post’s account was frozen for nine months, only four and a half years ago, for stating that a male public official who claimed to be a woman was, in fact, a “man.”

The freeze came on the heels of the satirical site The Babylon Bee being locked out over a joke on the same topic. Before either, independent journalist Meghan Murphy had been permanently banned from Twitter for saying “men aren’t women.”

If a statement that basic could be deemed “hateful conduct” under Twitter’s rules, anything truly hateful was likely to be mass-reported and removed. So, although some accounts did post extreme content, the average user rarely saw the worst of it, and what they did see could be dismissed as fringe. Also, double standards were a thing. The main Iranian Ayatollah could call for the mass death of Jews on Twitter, and he was not banned. This was more or less my own experience of the platform.

All that changed when Musk took over. For the first few months, users could speak far more freely, even on forbidden topics that might once have been labeled “misinformation.” The Bee, The Christian Post, and Murphy were all allowed back to say, plainly and accurately, that men are not women.

But free speech means free speech for everyone, including the most morally repugnant voices. From a First Amendment standpoint, that’s a constitutional guarantee.

This open digital public square, however, brought a further challenge: monetization and the algorithm.

As time went on, I began to see accounts posting disturbingly vile content, antisemitic, racist, and chauvinist, some of it invoking Christ’s name. Freed from the heavy censorship of the past, many indulged their flesh and posted their worst impulses.

The view counts that Musk’s team added made clear that the worst accounts were gaining enormous algorithmic traction. Inflammatory content went viral, while thoughtful insights, unless posted by a user with a large following, drew comparatively little engagement.

Several months ago, after noticing a sharp uptick in virulent antisemitic posts complete with #ChristIsKing hashtags, I tweeted, “If you hate Jews, you hate Jesus.” Within a short time, I was deluged with filth. Some of it may have come from bots, but much of it looked to be from Holocaust deniers and white supremacists coming out of the woodwork, some calling me a “zio” and other foul names. You’d have thought I was on Gab. The flood of bile grew far worse after the October 7 terror attack and as the Israel-Gaza war unfolded.

It is tempting to dismiss this as fringe, especially because under pre-Musk Twitter, mainstream opinions like “men aren’t women” were enough to earn a ban. In what some call the era of Woke 1.0, a good-faith disagreement with a social-justice leftist over any of their pet policies could get you labeled a “racist” or “white supremacist.”

The environment on X has shifted markedly since 2023. Leftists who prefer echo chambers have migrated to Bluesky. Meanwhile, the fringe right, the kind that would have been censored under the old regime, now shares the platform with ordinary people who simply say sex is real, and actual poison is spreading like gangrene. Some ideologically motivated bad actors are working deliberately to cultivate grievance among disaffected young people, especially men, and to get them to scapegoat Jews, racial minorities, and women for all their problems.

This is moral filth, and it must be wholly rejected.

To pastors and ministry leaders who don’t spend much time online: if you have young people in your church or orbit, you’re probably already seeing evidence of this, but the problem is far more pervasive than you realize.

The digital landscape changes extremely fast. You have a turbo-cancerous beast of vicious moral reprobation on your hands that seemingly came out of nowhere. But “nowhere” is online, and barring a miracle, it will get worse.

Gone are the days when you could credibly say that the fringe, weird churches mass media has used to caricature ordinary, Bible-believing Christians don’t represent your average believer. Many shyster pastor-grifters online have cultivated followings of tens of thousands of struggling young people. They promote ungodly, racist, chauvinist, and vengeful perversions of the Gospel that many thought were long a thing of the past, and they are cashing in.

Zoom out, and I believe those pushing these distortions are a minority, amplified because sensational content goes viral. But many of the cartoonish stereotypes disingenuously hurled at sincere Christians over the years now have teeth.

May God grant every believer in Jesus supernatural wisdom in this time and the boldness to confront this exploding evil.

Send news tips to: brandon.showalter@christianpost.com Listen to Brandon Showalter's Life in the Kingdom podcast at The Christian Post and edifi app Follow Brandon Showalter on Facebook: BrandonMarkShowalter Follow on Twitter: @BrandonMShow

Was this article helpful?

Become a CP Insider.
Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone.

The truth has a cost, and Insiders help carry it.
A dollar from an Insider comes with no strings attached. It keeps our reporters on the story, keeps our journalism open to everyone, and keeps every editorial decision in the newsroom, where it belongs.

Become a CP Insider and choose the amount you want to pay. You can change, pause or cancel anytime. As a thank-you, you’ll get:

  • The Insider Newsletter, a members-only monthly letter from our newsroom

  • Ad-free reading across christianpost.com


From as low as $8.25/month
Prefer to give once?

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles.
Return to homepage.

Most Popular