Bucking trend, Redeemer Presbyterian Church drops $30M for building in all-cash deal

Redeemer Presbyterian Church
Redeemer Presbyterian Church recently purchase this building at 150 East 91st Street in New York, NY, for .5 million. |

NEW YORK — Bucking an ongoing trend of cash-strapped churches selling their buildings to developers to survive, Redeemer Presbyterian Church, founded by Pastor Tim Keller in 1989, has spent nearly $30 million in an all-cash deal to secure a building on Manhattan’s Upper East Side to house a new campus in its family of churches.

The church closed on a multifamily building located at 150 East 91st Street last Friday for $29.5 million, the Commercial Observer reported. The building was sold by GPG Properties which has owned it since the 1960s.

Redeemer did not immediately respond to a request for comment from The Christian Post on the purchase Tuesday, but the Rev. Dr. Abe Cho, senior pastor of Redeemer Presbyterian Church East Side, told the CO that the new acquisition will help the church better serve its community.

“Redeemer looks forward to having not only a local presence on the Upper East Side that will allow us to better serve our congregants but also a community and cultural space that contributes to the flourishing of our neighbors,” Cho said.

The 21,342 square-foot building, which was constructed in 1910, will boast a sanctuary as well as meeting rooms and a cultural space when Redeemer converts it from a multi-family building.

“Our family has been part of the Upper East Side community since the 1930s,” Jason Glick, managing principal of GPG, said about the sale, according to the CO. “We are thrilled that the sale of this property will yield an opportunity for Redeemer to create a permanent Upper East Side presence and continue to serve the community.” 

Cushman & Wakefield, a global commercial real estate services firm, represented GPG in making the deal with Redeemer. C&W representative Hunter Moss said, “It’s really a feel-good deal.”

“There were no problems, no messing around. Everyone did what they said they were going to do,” he added.

The deals was reportedly 16 months in the making and was noted as the second-largest sale to close on the Upper East Side in 2020.  C&W previously worked with the church to acquire its Upper West Side headquarters at 150 West 83rd Street in 2012. The church converted a then-parking garage to the building that exists today, CO said. 

While many churches still retain their buildings in Manhattan, some with significant real estate holdings, The New York Times reported last October that from 2013 to 2018, more than three dozen houses of worship and similar buildings in Manhattan were razed or redeveloped to make way for different uses as churches faced declining membership and mounting bills.

In a report earlier this year, CP also highlighted how some churches have found creative ways to generate income while serving a public good by partnering with developers to create more affordable housing.

Trinity Wall Street Episcopal Church in Lower Manhattan, the richest Episcopal church in the world and one of New York City’s most influential players in the real estate market, was noted as boasting a diverse real estate investment portfolio worth $6 billion thanks in large part to a gift of 215 acres of land from Queen Anne in 1705. The church still owns about 14 acres of that grant and has evolved into a “big time” developer itself.

Free CP Newsletters

Join over 250,000 others to get the top stories curated daily, plus special offers!


Most Popular

More In Church & Ministries