Engaging views and analysis from outside contributors on the issues affecting society and faith today.

CP VOICES do not necessarily reflect the views of The Christian Post. Opinions expressed are solely those of the author(s).

 Voices |

The Christmas story template from which all other stories are drawn

Growing up in Greensboro, North Carolina, my grade school education included learning about one of the town’s more famous past residents William Sydney Porter.  Does this name ring a bell?  Perhaps you’ve heard of his pseudonym, “O’ Henry.”  Porter (1862-1910) left employment in his family’s local drug store to establish himself as a writer.  He is remembered for crafting one of America’s best-loved short stories The Gift of the Magi.

The plotline of O’Henry’s Christmas story has captivated readers around the globe: a young couple, deeply in love but financially poor, sacrifices greatly in order to give gifts to each other.  The husband sells an heirloom pocket watch in order to buy his wife a set of combs and pins for her hair (a century ago such things were made of tortoise shell, pearl, or ivory, and were very expensive).  The wife—whose lovely hair was her pride and joy—sells it in order to buy the husband a gold chain for his beloved watch.

Though selfless love is certainly demonstrated in their actions, as a child this Catch-22 story frustrated me.  It took a few years of reading before I understood that the author was renowned for such surprise endings.  It would be even longer before I understood the ultimate act of sacrificial love on which O’Henry’s story was based.

The Old Testament book of Isaiah points to the coming Savior in a number of key passages. Isaiah famously speaks of the one who would someday be, “led like a Lamb to slaughter” (53:7), and “by Whose stripes we are healed (Is. 53:5; I Peter 2:24).  Writing around 750 BC, Isaiah amazingly portrays scenes from the Savior’s time on earth that we would later read about in the Gospels: He would be born of a virgin (c.f., Isaiah 7:14 and Lk. 1:34).  The Messiah would be God incarnate (c.f. Is. 9:6 and Mark 14:61-61, and John 10:30-33).  He would be beaten beyond recognition, even before being put to death on the Cross (c.f. Is. 52:14 and Matthew 27:26-31).

Here is where the facts about Christmas might seem to be as hard to reconcile as the ending of an O’Henry tale: clearly, the Father loves and cherishes His unique and only Son, Jesus.  So much so that when Christ was suffering for the sins of the world and dying on the Cross, the Father looked away.  Though no one fully understands how, for the first and only time in all of eternity the Father and the Son were separated.  As Christ’s horrific betrayal, woundings, and death culminated, it is a wonder that the wrath of God didn’t erupt onto the entire globe!

The irony is that Isaiah 53:10 says, “It pleased the Father to bruise Him” (literally, “to crush Him”).  How can this be?  How could God possibly have been pleased with the vicious execution of the One called “His beloved Son”?  How could the hateful and brutal treatment of Jesus have been pleasing to the Father?

The wording of Isaiah and similar passages like John 3:16 show the compassionate heart of the Father:  If it means that you would be saved—restored in this life, and saved from hell in the next—the Father’s heart in Isaiah 53:10 is essentially saying to all of us, “For your precious soul . . . Happy to do it.  No problem.  I did all of this because I love you.”

Unlike even the best human writers, God leaves no holes in the plotline of His amazing drama!  There is—ultimately—no unresolved tension in the story God has crafted.  Think about it:  In Jesus’ coming to earth, the Author wrote Himself into the play.  And He invites you, through faith in Christ, to enter into the story!

Christ’s presence in the Bible and His work throughout history truly is “Good News” and the greatest story ever told.  In love, God sent His Son.  In love, the Son died and arose.  And in love, we meet Jesus personally.

What makes this even more than just “a great story” is the element that no other dramatist could include: the cliffhanger story of Jesus happens also to be… reality.

Alex McFarland is a religion and culture expert, a national talk show host and speaker, author of 18 books and the host of over 40 Truth for a New Generation conferences. For more information, visit

Was this article helpful?

Want more articles like this?

Help keep The Christian Post free for everyone by making a one-time donation today.

We’re sorry to hear that.

Hope you’ll give us another try and check out some other articles. Return to homepage.

Free Religious Freedom Updates

Join thousands of others to get the FREEDOM POST newsletter for free, sent twice a week from The Christian Post.

Most Popular

Free Religious Freedom Updates

A religious liberty newsletter that is a must-read for people of faith.

More In Opinion